Marry a lover, and his wife and children emigrate.

2 1 year later, 165438+20221October 23rd, the case of "killing his wife and son" in Guizhou was retried in the People's Court of Huaxi District, Guiyang City, Guizhou Province.

Due to the epidemic situation, Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court tried Li's intentional homicide retrial in Huaxi District Court of Guiyang City. Photo courtesy of respondents

The prosecution alleged that in the early morning of March 20th, 20001year, Li, then director of the iron casting workshop and secretary of the Party branch of the Ironmaking Plant of Liupanshui Shuicheng Iron and Steel Co., Ltd., Guizhou Province, killed his wife and son, and later found his lover Meng Mohong to dismember the body and transfer it to the blast furnace of the steelmaking plant for incineration.

On September 5438+0, 2006, Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court sentenced Li to intentional homicide, sentenced to death, deprived of political rights for life, and convicted Meng Mohong of sheltering, and sentenced him to 8 years in prison.

200 1 1 1 20, the second instance of Guizhou Provincial High Court ruled that the case was sent back to Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court for retrial on the grounds of "unclear facts and insufficient evidence".

After the retrial of Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court, the first-instance judgment was made again on June 5438+February 1 day, 2003. Li was still convicted of intentional homicide and sentenced to death with a suspended execution. Meng Mohong committed the crime of harboring and was still sentenced to 8 years. Li refused to accept and appealed to. On June 65438+1October 65438+February 2004, the Guizhou Provincial High Court made a final ruling and upheld the original judgment.

After being imprisoned, Li continued to complain. As the victim's family, Li's parents-in-law also ran for many years to complain for Li.

After continuous appeals, on May 27, 2006, the Guizhou Provincial High Court decided to start a retrial of this case. The Higher People's Court of Guizhou Province held that the original procedure of first instance violated the relevant procedural provisions of witnesses' testifying in court, presenting appraisal conclusions and re-appraising. The original judgment found that there were doubts and contradictions in the criminal facts of Li's intentional homicide, which may affect the fair trial. Therefore, the original judgment of the first and second instance was revoked and sent back to the Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court for retrial.

Li's second brother165438+1October 24th told this newspaper that Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court found another defendant in the original trial, Li's former mistress Meng Mohong, and informed him to appear in court again. At the same time, two police officers handling the Li case appeared in court for court investigation.

The victim's mother, Zhang, continued to appeal for her son-in-law, Li, and did not participate in the retrial because of physical discomfort.

The original trial was accused of "killing his wife and son" with his lover.

Continuing to appeal, the retrial of Li's case of "killing his wife and son" was held on June 23rd 165438. Next month, 53-year-old Li will be released from prison.

The case happened in the early morning of March 20th, 20001year. At that time, Li in the dock was proud of his life and served as the director of the cast iron workshop and secretary of the party branch of the ironmaking plant of Liupanshui Shuicheng Iron and Steel Co., Ltd. in Guizhou

At the first trial, the prosecution accused Li of maliciously strangling his wife Xie Chuming when she came home in the early morning of March 20, 2000/KLOC-0, while she was not paying attention, remembering the discord between them since May 2000. In the process, the crying 3-year-old son was killed by a pillow. Li goes to work normally during the day. After dark that night, he found an extramarital affair person Meng Mohong to assist in handling it. They decomposed the body together and put it in four woven bags. Subsequently, Meng Mohong used baskets to transfer the bodies to the blast furnace of the iron works in batches for burning, while Li cleaned the room.

When Li and Xie Chuming were in college, they were remake by our reporter Jiaming Wei.

The newspaper previously reported that Xie Chuming and Li Yushan were high school classmates and later admitted to the same university in Guizhou. In the second year of college, Li and his "goddess" Xie Chuming came together.

1994, Xie chuming graduated from university and went to work in Shuigang power plant. Li followed her into Shuigang. Li's colleague Gong Dingjun, an employee of Shuigang Ironmaking Plant, told this newspaper that Li was originally assigned to teach in Liupanshui TV University, but he still chose to start from the front-line technical work and became the first college student to enter the material transportation workshop of the ironmaking plant at that time. Due to hard work and excellent business, Li was promoted quickly in the next five years, and became the director of the cast iron workshop and secretary of the party branch all the way, with a bright future.

1At the end of 1996, Li and Xie Chuming registered to get married, and held a wedding in March of the following year, and they had children soon after marriage.

To outsiders, Li Xie and his wife seem to live a happy life. Because of the extramarital affair between Li and Meng Mohong, Xie Chuming once wrote in his suicide note: "I can't bear the sudden darkness."

Meng Mohong is from Quyang County, Hebei Province. He came to Shuigang with his parents in his early years, and his father was an old worker in the transportation department of Shuigang. Meng Mohong also entered Shuigang after graduating from high school. At first, he was a canteen cook, and later he was transferred to the material transportation workshop as a belt worker.

According to Hui Zhou, an employee of Shuigang and a former friend of Xie Chuming, Meng Mohong is about 1.6 meters tall, with a round face and big eyes. He is not beautiful, and he seldom talks to people.

The relationship between Li and Meng Mohong was established in199565438+February, and continued intermittently until marriage. In a few years, Meng Mohong also had many miscarriages because of Li. Meng Mohong said in the original transcript that the two had true feelings. Li once said that only with her can she get peace of mind.

At the beginning of 2000, this underground situation that lasted for many years was known by Xie Chuming. Li said that at that time, Meng asked him to divorce and marry her, but he didn't agree, so Meng Mohong went to the Li family to find Xie Chuming's showdown.

After learning that her husband was having an affair, Xie Chuming was hit hard. She offered to divorce Li, but Li refused.

Li said that he tried his best to save it, and he knelt down to apologize to Xie Chuming, and finally got his wife's forgiveness. However, Meng Mohong's entanglement did not stop.

In the first half of 2000, Meng Mohong made many noises in the workshop. In July of that year, she also stabbed Li Yu's front waist with a knife. I remember my brother's injury deeply, but at that time, Xie Chuming concealed her husband's medicine from his family, saying that Li accidentally hurt himself at work.

On October 25th, 65438/KLOC-0, Meng Mohong reported to the criminal investigation department of Shuigang Public Security Bureau that Li raped him in his office on the evening of September 2nd. This incident was later proved to be a false accusation. Li Yu was in Guiyang the night before, but not in Liupanshui at all.

In September 2000, Meng Mohong took a man to Xie Chuming's house and smashed his glass. 1 10 After the police arrived, Meng Mohong had an argument with Li and said, "I don't know how your family died."

Later, Meng Mohong sued Xie Chuming in the Zhongshan District People's Court of Liupanshui City on the grounds that Xie Chuming called her to scold her, causing adverse effects in the unit and infringing on her reputation. In June 5438+the following year 10, both parties filed a lawsuit against Bogongtang.

However, before the trial, Xie Chuming and his son were killed, while Li and Meng Mohong were suspects in the case of "killing his wife and killing his son".

Liupanshui City Procuratorate 200 1 accused that the relationship between husband and wife had deteriorated since Xie Chuming discovered that there was a woman outside Li in May 2000. In the early morning of March 20th, 20001year, Li went home and strangled Xie Chuming, and then strangled his waking son with a pillow. Until 9 o'clock on the evening of the 20th, Li found Meng Mohong. With the help of Li's hands and Meng, he dismembered the bodies of the mother and son and put them in four woven bags. Meng carried Xie Chuming's trunk and lower limbs to the blast furnace with his back, and then returned. He transferred the remaining bodies to Meng's temporary residence and Room 304 of the ironmaking women's singles building in three times, and then carried them to the blast furnace with his back.

There is still blood on the wall of Li's bedroom. Our reporter Wei Jiaming

My parents-in-law helped my son-in-law appeal for retrial.

Although at the trial of the first instance, Li confessed to the fact that he was tortured to extract a confession, and said that he and his wife had a good relationship and had no motive to kill. He was framed by Meng Mohong. However, Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court made a first-instance judgment in September, 20001year, holding that Li constituted the crime of intentional homicide, was sentenced to death and deprived of political rights for life, and Meng Mohong constituted the crime of shielding, and was sentenced to 8 years in prison.

Li, who refused to accept the verdict, appealed. 200 1 165438 The second instance of Guizhou Provincial High Court ruled that the case was sent back to Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court for retrial on the grounds of "unclear facts and insufficient evidence".

On June 5438+February 1 day, 2003, Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court found Li guilty of intentional homicide again, but sentenced him to death with a suspended execution. For Li's second appeal, the Guizhou Provincial High Court made a final ruling on June 65438+10/October 65438+February 2004, and upheld the first-instance judgment.

After going to prison, he insisted on complaining to Li. Among the people who supported him were the parents of the victims Xie Chuming, Xie and Zhang.

In an interview with the newspaper, Zhang said that on June 29, 2006, at 5438+0, she insisted on going to the detention center to meet Li despite the opposition of other children. Through the glass, Li cried and said that he didn't kill anyone. After talking with several witnesses in the case, she strengthened her son-in-law's belief that he didn't kill anyone.

Zhang asked Li to write down his contacts with Meng Mohong in detail. Holding Li's handwritten materials, Zhang and Xie traveled to Dafang County and Shuicheng to report the situation to government departments at all levels.

According to Zhang's personal complaint, he asked the government to make a fair judgment, find out the real murderer, and speak out for those who died unjustly. The staff who received her was greatly surprised: "I have never seen the victim's family plead for the murderer."

Li Yushan, his family and his parents-in-law kept complaining, which finally turned the case around. On May 27th, 20 16, Guizhou Provincial High Court decided to start a retrial of the case.

On September 28, 2020, the Guizhou Provincial High Court publicly pronounced the case of Li's intentional homicide. The Higher People's Court of Guizhou Province held that the original procedure of first instance violated the relevant procedural provisions of witnesses' testifying in court, presenting appraisal conclusions and re-appraising. The original judgment found that there were doubts and contradictions in the criminal facts of Li's intentional homicide, which may affect the fair trial. Therefore, the original judgments of the first and second instance were revoked and sent back to Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court for retrial.

Li Yushan told the newspaper that Zhang, who had made a lot of efforts for retrial, did not appear in court due to physical discomfort. Because the old man had another cerebral hemorrhage on 202 1, and it was more serious than before, he couldn't bear to torture such a seriously ill old man with expectation and hope. "The trial is over, go back to Bijie and tell her the situation."

Another defendant in the original trial appeared in court again, and the police handling the case appeared in court for court investigation.

Li said that in this retrial, the Liupanshui Intermediate People's Court found the defendant Meng Mohong, whose whereabouts were unknown before, and informed her to appear in court again. Meng Mohong also attended the trial of165438+1October 23rd and 24th.

Lawyer Zhou Zhaocheng, Li's defender, said that the two-day trial fully guaranteed the litigation rights of both the prosecution and the defense, and also guaranteed Li's litigation rights. Li and Meng Mohong both appeared in court. In the face of inquiries from prosecutors and defenders, Meng Mohong replied that he could not remember or was unclear. He focused on the trajectory and time of Li's activities on March 6 +09 and March 20.

Zhou Zhaocheng said that it is doubtful whether Li is the real murderer in this case. After many visits and investigations, the existing evidence shows that Li has no motive for committing crimes and has no time to kill or dismember his body. The original judgment found that Li "killed his wife and killed his son", and only the confessions of Li and Meng Mohong lacked objective evidence. Therefore, for the defense of this case, he continued to defend Li's innocence like his former lawyer.

Zhou Zhaocheng said that the court agreed to the defender's request to let the police handling Li's case appear in court for court investigation.

Attending the trial told reporters that1October 23rd, 165438+ two investigators handling Li's case came to the court to investigate. In court, Li asked investigators about nine guilty confessions from "being summoned on March 28th, 2000/KLOC-0" to "being detained on April 4th", and told the court that at that time, the police baked him with high-power electric lights, prevented him from eating, drinking and sleeping, and forced him to confess, and he was beaten to death.

He said that the time he learned from the trial transcript confirmed that the transcript of Li was formed in the early hours of the morning. Investigators responded in court that they did not extort a confession from Li by torture, and the transcript was formed in the early hours of the morning. Because Li was sleeping during the day, he was interrogated at night.

In addition, the court also agreed to the defender's application and allowed expert assistants to participate in the trial. Li Yushan said that on June 25th, the well-known forensic doctor 165438+ Hu Zhiqiang, who had participated in the Nie Shubin case, the case and the Nianbin case, will appear in court to express his opinions on the Li case.

Li and his wife and children took a group photo while playing in Hongfu Temple. Our reporter Jiaming Wei remake.

Regarding the time when Li committed the crime, the newspaper reported earlier that on the evening of March 1 2006, two key witnesses got along with Li and Xie Chuming respectively, one was Gong Dingjun, and the other was. At 8 o'clock that night, the two of them went to visit the Li family. On the way, another friend of Li's called out for a frying pan. Gong Dingjun went on a date with Li, and Zhou Hui stayed at home with Xie Chuming.

That night 10: 30, pregnant Hui Zhou didn't feel well, so she went home early. She told the newspaper that before going out, she looked at the clock above the TV. It was exactly half past ten.

Half an hour later, Gong Dingjun came to meet Li Jia, but no one answered no matter how he knocked at the door. He turned to the telephone booth downstairs and called, but no one answered. At this time, Gong Dingjun felt a little strange and called Li. At that time, Li Zheng and several other friends were playing in the Daguangming Hotel, and didn't go home until three o'clock in the morning, only to find that his wife and children had disappeared.

For many years, Gong Dingjun has always believed that something happened between Xie Chuming and his mother at1March 9 10: 30 and10/min. "Their phone is by the bed. How could they not hear? How can normal people fall asleep in half an hour? Why don't they wake up when knocking at the door? "

Another key witness in this case is Yang Huanmu, an employee of Shuigang who lives in Room 30 1 of the single building. During the field interview of the 20 16 paper, Yang Huanmu confidently told the reporter that he was working on the report from the evening of March 19 to the early morning of March 20, 200 18, so he stayed up all night. At about one or two in the morning, he saw a woman moving something from the Li family. He observed it carefully with a telescope. This woman is Meng. The newspaper noted that according to the witness time provided by Yang Huanmu, Li did not go home when Meng Mohong moved things.

"The evidence proves that Li Yu did not have the time and motivation to commit crimes before, and we hope that he can be acquitted in court." Li Yushan said, however, some bad signs appeared in the trial on1October 23rd, and the statements of some witnesses changed.

Li told the newspaper through his lawyer that if he could regain his freedom, he would like to see his mother-in-law Zhang most. "After my mother left, she was the only person I cared about in this world." He said he would sincerely apologize to his mother-in-law