Where is the legend of Hongmen Banquet inconsistent with history? Did Han Xin die that badly? My history is not good, please answer my uncle and aunt.

First, the theme is inconsistent. The previous paragraph shows the interests of the people and the country; However, in the last paragraph, the theme of personal bleak promotion in his later years is "no one around him can be trusted".

Second, the role of "Yu Ji" is the crowning touch in failure. Whether the image of Liu Yifei's maid has classical temperament is left aside for the time being. In history, she was originally a woman who was generally prominent. On the one hand, she is ambiguous with Liu Bang, on the other hand, her love with Xiang Yu is not deep. Give birth to an eternal figure, made like a "chicken rib." This is the actor's failure, but also the director's failure in casting and directing the play.

Third, the topic of "chess is a metaphor for the world" is very good, but it has not been consistently explained in depth. Originally, the film began with "chess" and ended with "chess", but it was completely dismembered by the fragmentation of the plot, which made people feel that chess was only a prop, not a theme.

Fourth, contradictions. At the beginning, the teacher explained to ordinary students the seats of the year and sat north and south, and so did the follow-up films, but Lao Zhang Liang, who scared the students to death, said no, are you crazy? Later, I moved to an empty memorial tablet from nowhere and put it next to Xiang Yu's memorial tablet. Don't let go early and don't let go late. Since you can freely enter and leave the palace, why do you come to pay homage now?

5. typos. If a book is published, the typo rate will reach three ten thousandths, the book will be burned as much as it is printed, and the publishing house will be punished. But I can find as many as eight typos and other words in the subtitles of the film, and the phenomenon that the subtitles don't match the lines has appeared two or three times (I can't remember the details).

Sixth, teach bad children. Chinese mainland didn't receive any history education. Although Historical Records and Hanshu can't be said to be objective history, at least people don't have as many tricks as this screenwriter. In Hong Men fire, Xiang Yu was stabbed to death by Yu Ji. . . Too many. Where is the so-called "hongmen banquet" and "banquet"? The key plot is either playing chess or fighting to the death. Several founding generals were inexplicably killed because of Fan Zeng's last plan?

Seven, the plot is tangled, very stingy. How clever Liang was persuaded by Liu Bang's subtotal. Later, Liu Bang said "chop" and then smiled cunningly. It is simply to demote the founding emperor of Han directly back to Xiao Pei and become a street hooligan-carving tricks and buying people's hearts. Similar small emotions, small conflicts and small expressions all show China's lackluster cast and weak directing skills.

Eight, personality confession is ridiculous. In the previous scene, in order to expose Liu Bang, Xiao He, Xia Houying and others, through a dialogue, we directly called names, oh! The audience will know who is who as soon as they hear it. I don't say, it is this kind of first-name person who doesn't talk, but only says that this kind of play can be played to the end. As a result, in addition to the above one, Xiang Yu and his gang also used one, and then they stopped playing!

Finally, the death of Han Xin. Historically, after Emperor Gaozu Liu Bang defeated his main rival Xiang Yu, Han Xin's power was weakened again and again. Finally, Han Xin was tricked into the palace by Lv Zhi (that is, Lv Hou) and Xiao He, and was executed in the bell room of Changle Palace.