Immigration reversal story

As a hilarious New Year film, the film has a funny point, and the big reversal at the end is the crowning touch, returning to the theme of "exploring cases".

Let's comb the plot again. Is Yi Song the murderer? He was not arrested at last, which means that Qin Feng didn't call the police, and there is no evidence to prove that Yi Song is the murderer. Personally, I don't think Yi Song should be the murderer.

But through the dialogue at the end, we can find that Yi Song is not a simple detective lover, and he still hides something. At the beginning, everyone's goal was easy to lock in him, because he met all the characteristics of the crime. This is actually a big question. Is it accidental that two detective gods misjudged the second and third place at the same time?

On the other hand, Qin Feng. At the end, Qin Feng's ambiguous smile, overconfident judgment and eagerness to explore the results tend to be blackened.

When you look into the abyss, the abyss looks at you.

Yi Song saw Qin Feng's animal nature, and all his judgments were not based on human nature. When confronted with the murderer, he said that the murderer misinterpreted Yin and Yang, pushing them to the extremes of divinity and animality, and failed to see human nature. However, after Yi Song rescued Qin Feng, Qin Feng's quick analysis and judgment also exposed his animal nature.

In the movie, Qin Feng had another chance to face the murderer. He stood opposite the murderer at the station. The murderer even took off his hat. Is it absolutely certain that the murderer will not be recognized in the dark? After the murderer showed his scalpel, Qin Feng was very scared, but was it just because of fear? Later, when he was discovered by Tang Ren, he squatted on the ground with no frightened expression. What did he think of when he faced it? What do you see?

Might as well boldly interpret, in fact, he knows each other, and this person is still an unspeakable object. The murderer was not the real murderer in the end, he was just manipulated by this person (this person is probably the mysterious Ah Q), and so was Yi Song.

Did kiko, a talented computer girl, really show up for that 5 million?

At that time, when Mr Q announced the sugar factory crisis, all Qin Feng's previous inferences were meaningless. Everyone got the news and went back to the starting point. In fact, the murderer is always in front of them. In order to ensure that the story develops in the direction that the murderer wants to go, and at the same time, the murderer is likely to have contact with Qin Feng (as just said, they probably know each other), so Q wants Qin Feng to participate in this game, especially to drive kiko to rescue Qin Feng.

As mentioned above, maybe the real Mr. Q hasn't appeared yet. He has been silently watching, remote control, in fact, is a close contact with mahjong. And Qin Feng was manipulated without knowing it.

The above is only a personal guess, welcome to communicate ~

For a long time, I saw many wonderful comments.

So I decided to put it together and post it. Everyone has a lot of opinions:

The following is a compilation comment ~

Xiao Xu _b383:

Just looking back, I am also puzzled. At first, I thought Yi Song was Q, but at the end of the story, I specifically said that the login id was not in Canada or the United States.

After watching the whole movie, I thought I could understand the doctor's motive for killing, but in the end, I thought the doctor's motive for killing was too far-fetched. Finally, he stressed that Song Yiyi started using his left hand to prove that he didn't kill the role of Wang Xun in the future, thus proving his innocence? Or do you want to prove that he was involved in the whole serial killer case from the beginning, not just to hate Wang Xun, but to kill him?

It is illogical to jump back to the role of a doctor and kill so many people in cold blood to save his life, but he finally chose to commit suicide by cutting his neck. But in the end, he pointed the finger at doctors, symbols, killings, motives, shrines and understanding China culture. And Song Yiling took the lead in killing people in the park. He knew that the murderer would kill people?

Also, at that time, the murderer was suspected of committing a crime, but the camera only caught them chasing the murderer and flashed by. It was Yi Song who left it to report to the police. Was that man really killed by Yi Song? In the sugar factory, it was also the old Q who gave the first order to kill. This old q doesn't like solving crimes, but prefers to guide them to witness murders. On the surface, Yi Song and the doctor are both suspected of killing people, both with their left hands, but the old Q that has been mentioned all the time seems to have something to do with them.

If there is a follow-up to explain the content of 2, I can still think it is a rigorous film. If there is no connection between 2 and 1, I really think it is an anticlimactic film, and I don't know what the center is. Although he is a genius and a detective, according to the ending, he was seduced. For Song Yi, there are no charges. I chose the attitude of going home after investigating the case. After reading it, I really looked puzzled. Finally, the trailer in Tokyo, the appearance and face of the third-ranked Japanese, was completely incredible after the IQ was crushed. Well, I want to believe that this is a big movie. Today next year, I can solve this year's puzzle.

Society, my meow:

I think you forgot one detail. Borrowing records show that the doctor's wife borrowed it a long time ago, and Song was the last one to borrow it, so the contextual judgment here is that the doctor knows this way of killing, and Song should be killed in the first person. ....

Thinking of this, I suddenly realized that the logic here doesn't make sense. When they went to check the symbols, the second man was killed, and Song had already been found. When the first person was killed, because it was not the first scene, the symbol was not found, but another problem appeared. Qin Feng arrived at the place where the first person was found, and the reasoning was the first scene. Qin Feng reasoned that it was a community. Song said it was farther away at this time. Whether this mistake here can explain why Song reasoned with the first scene after the first person was killed, so it can guide Qin Feng to find the first scene smoothly, which can also perfectly explain why Song will have the borrowing history of that book, because he checked it before, so he knows his killing method.

As for the reversal in the ending, I prefer Qin Feng's reasoning, and the biggest question here lies in Q, is this person Song or Qin Feng? Both of them can make sense in reverse reasoning, but at the airport kiko said that this person is neither in Canada nor in the United States, divergent thinking, the United States has South America and North America, and the seventh uncle said that this person Lu had done human trafficking and sold it to South America.

One of my bold speculations is:

Ah Q is actually Song's sister.

She was sold to South America. Song had found or found her sister during this time, but because he was an illegal immigrant, he could not leave the United States and had to be repatriated. His sister was worried that she had thought of a way to kill her after learning about the murder, and asked his brother to help her find the book the first time. Everything behind it can be explained. Q Because she already knew the method of killing people, Song, the remote commander, replaced the original body with Lu's body when she killed people for the fourth time. This is a typical backdoor resin exchange. According to this logic, the whole event can basically be called perfect. The biggest loophole lies in the original body of his fourth murder. If this loophole can be removed, there will never be any loopholes in the whole incident. Perfect! ! !

Because reasoning can never arrest people, arresting people depends on evidence. What was the expression on the doctor's face when he dissected the fourth body, Lu? What happened? You think killing officer Chen is unbearable? Or he didn't kill the body at all! ! ! If the film can follow this logic, it will be perfectly interpreted and really impeccable! ! !

Phoenix _b9 1d:

A trilogy is almost enough for ordinary movies. I think the third movie should be the ending of Tang Tan. I don't think Qin Feng should be blacked out to the point of committing a crime, otherwise a movie will be blacked out, and the plot will be too fast.

"Tangtan 2" does leave us a lot of room for imagination, but there are also many doubts.

First of all, why was Qin Feng cheated at first, instead of being invited? The top people on PPT have been invited, so why not invite Qin Feng? I think this is a foreshadowing.

Second, why is Yi Song also left-handed? According to the plot, when Qin Feng found him, he should not have been fully exposed to the whole case. Without any information, he will know that the murderer is also left-handed? Why did the murderer's dead wife suddenly study a Taoist book, but the murderer only found five lines on it, so I think Yi Song is behind the murderer.

Third, Q can know the killer's next move before anyone else. Will a person with such a strong ability make Kiko find his position so easily? At the end of the film, Kiko found the place but didn't say anything, leaving us some room for imagination, or whether Kiko and Q have already met.

Ximu _:

I understand it this way. Qin Feng's "perfect crime" should refer to the way he solved the case. The process of his reasoning is in the form of returning to the crime scene. Want to solve the case only close to it, or even become it, so I think it is unlikely that Qin Feng will be hacked.

Touch _3b4d:

Yi Song may just be a pawn. He took revenge by killing people with five elements. Qin Feng's behavior has obviously completely fallen into criminal logic. If all behaviors are distinguished by divinity (that is, human nature mentioned in the play) and animality, there is only one answer in the end, that is, mixing animality and divinity can become real human nature, and misinterpreting human nature with one-sided philosophy. This is called blackening. So Yi Song said to him, don't stare at the abyss for too long, because the abyss is staring at you. This may be a warning that he used the case to kill people, and it is also a warning to Qin Feng not to be too addicted to the investigation and lose his humanity.