The son-in-law's family of three was killed by the old father-in-law, and the execution of the second instance of the Sichuan High Court was suspended. How did the court answer this?

The court's answer to this is that although the man has assassinated three people in a row, it has constituted the crime of intentional homicide, but the motive for committing the crime is not extremely bad, and the means of committing the crime is not extremely despicable. The injured party is also responsible for this incident, and the man voluntarily surrendered himself and pleaded guilty after committing the crime. Therefore, it will be handled as appropriate in the second trial, and the death penalty in the original trial will be immediately changed to a suspended death sentence.

Personally, I think the court's decision is reasonable and has certain basis. As the saying goes, "legal principle is nothing more than human feelings", different cases should be viewed from different angles, but the families of the victims are not satisfied with this judgment. At present, the victim's family has applied for retrial, hoping to get justice for the victim. Although the suspect in this case surrendered voluntarily, there were still some twists and turns in the trial. Let me take you back to this case:

Please click to enter the picture description (maximum 18 words).

I. Criminal process

The victims are a family of three, namely father Bo Zou (a pseudonym), mother Ju Yang (a pseudonym) and son Zou Tao (a pseudonym). This case is mainly caused by the struggle for custody of children. Zou Tao and his wife met in college, and they got married soon after graduation. After marriage, they gave birth to a daughter, which was supposed to be a happy family of three, but it became the beginning of a tragedy. Shortly after giving birth,

After that, Zou Tao simply moved out and submitted two divorce applications to the court, but none of them got the support of the court, so the contradiction intensified. The day before the incident, Zou Tao took his parents to his residence, and the next day he went to his father-in-law's house to talk about the custody of the children. That day, Zou Tao's wife went to work, and only the old couple took care of the children at home.

Please click to enter the picture description (maximum 18 words).

I thought it would be a calm negotiation, but as soon as Zou Tao's family of three entered the room, they began to rob the children. First, Zou Tao's mother-in-law was held down, and then the child in her arms was taken away. Zou Tao's wife's family always felt that Zou Tao didn't fulfill his father's responsibility and the children wouldn't give it to them. In the process, Zou Tao's father-in-law has been trying to stop their behavior, but it is useless. Later, he even started to do it. Zou Tao's father-in-law had to take out a boning knife, which was originally.

So Zou Tao's father-in-law picked up boning knife and stabbed Zou Tao twice. On the spot, Zou Tao lay motionless on the sofa, and then he stabbed Ju Yang with her baby in her arms twice. Bo Zou saw that his children and his wife were stabbed, so he jumped, and Bo Zou was stabbed. After committing the crime, he took the initiative to call 1 10, but the line was busy three times and could not be connected. Then he asked his daughter to call 120 and asked the property to call an ambulance. During this period, he never left, but in the end, Zou Tao and his mother Ju Yang died on the spot, and his father Bo Zou died the next day.

Please click to enter the picture description (maximum 18 words).

Second, the first-instance judgment

The case was tried by Chengdu Intermediate People's Court when it was judged in the first instance. At that time, the prosecution believed that the criminal suspect stabbed three people with a knife and killed them, which had violated the criminal law and constituted the crime of intentional homicide, and should be investigated for criminal responsibility. Therefore, the suspect was sentenced to death and deprived of political rights for life.

At that time, the defender also put forward a defense, arguing that the suspect was not premeditated murder, but self-defense and should be given a lighter punishment. However, the court did not adopt the defender's opinion, so after the verdict was pronounced, the suspect appealed.

Please click to enter the picture description (maximum 18 words).

Third, the judgment of second instance

The second trial was held in Sichuan Higher People's Court. At the second trial, he believed that the suspect was an adult and should know that stabbing others would lead to his own death and serious consequences. Therefore, the criminal suspect's charges are both subjective and objective.

However, the criminal suspect belongs to a passionate crime and has the mentality of confessing and repenting, which has not caused extremely bad influence in society. After stabbing the victim, he did not continue to hurt, so he was sentenced to death with a suspended execution. However, the victim's family said that they had never participated in the second trial and did not know that there was such a judgment. When I saw the official account of WeChat and the lawyer, I realized that the suspect had changed from a suspended death sentence to a suspended death sentence. The families of the victims feel that this is a family life, and this result is unacceptable.

Please click to enter the picture description (maximum 18 words).

Conclusion:

Personally, no matter what happens, no matter how angry you are at that time, please stay rational and don't be impulsive, because a momentary impulse may hurt many people, not only yourself, but also others. As an adult, you should learn to manage your emotions.

I don't think anyone is right or wrong in this judgment, but I stand from different angles and positions, but I will bear the responsibility of doing something wrong anyway. Now I only hope that the two families can get out of their grief as soon as possible, and things can be solved as soon as possible, so that the deceased can rest in peace as soon as possible!