Is it reasonable to analyze the Taliban historically? what do you think?

Recently, many people are asking whether the Taliban is good or bad. This problem is actually very complicated. The definition of good and bad has never really been defined. From different angles, we have different definitions of good and bad.

First of all, let me tell you that the Taliban in Afghanistan and Pakistan are two different things. The Taliban in Pakistan is usually regarded as a terrorist organization. The Taliban in Afghanistan have publicly stated that they prohibit any individual or organization from using Afghan territory to threaten other countries, and the Afghan government has always kept in touch with the international community. The Pakistani Taliban is only a small branch independent of the Afghan Taliban, and has no practical relationship with the Afghan Taliban.

At first, the Taliban meant students in Islamic religious schools, but this name is what teachers in Islamic religious schools call students, which is another special name for teachers to call his students. That's what I meant at first.

However, it was not until after 1994 that the Taliban movement rose in Afghanistan and seized the Kabul regime in 1996 that the Taliban had special political significance. In short, it has become synonymous with Islamic fundamentalist movement.

The last Taliban is 1994, 1 1. At that time, in order to protect a motorcade trying to open the trade between Pakistan and Central Asia, they succeeded in one fell swoop and stepped onto the historical stage. The founder of the Taliban is Marvi Omar, and most of the Taliban are Islamic students in refugee camps in Afghanistan. The initial slogan of the Taliban was "eradicate warlords, rebuild the country and establish a real Islamic regime", and then it was a perennial war with the Afghan regime.

Murvi Omar was born in a remote mountain village in Afghanistan, and his parents were landless farm labourers. 1979 After the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, Murvi Omar's family was forced to emigrate, and finally Murvi Omar also participated in the anti-Soviet war. During the war, his fighting capacity was amazing, and he soon became a deputy commander, and he had a good relationship with bin Laden.

After Mulvi Omar became a Mullah in 1980, he started a religious school to support his family, and then participated in the anti-Soviet war until the Soviet army retreated.

After the Soviet army retreated, he returned to his hometown to continue teaching, but civil strife among warlords broke out in China. This changed Murvi Omar's mentality. 1994, Mulvi Omar established the Taliban by punishing local warlords who bullied female students and mobilizing religious students to take over their posts. The slogan is "eradicate warlords, rebuild the country" and "establish a real Islamic regime". This slogan is completely different from the melee of other warlords, so it has won the support of many people. In March 1996, Marvi was elected as the leader, and in September 1996, the Taliban captured the capital Kabul. 200 1 September 2000 1 1 incident was launched, then the United States entered Afghanistan, the Taliban collapsed, and the rest continued to fight in mountainous areas.

This is the predecessor of the Taliban. After reading it, you will feel that the Taliban seem to have done nothing bad except an attack on 9. 1 1. Don't jump to conclusions, and then look at other aspects of the Taliban.

Mulvi Omar's understanding of Islamic teachings is extremely extreme, and his understanding of Islamic teachings is very narrow, so his extreme discrimination against women is so extreme that women have no rights at all and have completely become a tool, not only for women, but also for many incredible prohibitions in other aspects. They say the music can't stop.

So from our current point of view, I think the Taliban is not good. They have done too many extreme things. And they don't respect women, don't care about the world cultural heritage, and wantonly destroy it. Even if you have a good goal, you can't achieve it by such violent means.

But from the Afghan people's point of view, the Taliban may be good, but some Taliban bans make them very scared, so it is really difficult to tell whether it is good or bad.