Zhang Yan’s latest progress

Victim’s family: We were stunned when we saw the identification conclusion!

On November 12, 2012, Wang Yanli’s husband Wang Leqi received a notice of appraisal conclusion from the Lanshan Branch of the Linyi Public Security Bureau. The bureau hired relevant personnel to conduct an “evaluation of Zhang Yan’s mental state at the time of the crime.” and criminal responsibility" appraisal, the appraisal conclusion was "1. Acute transient psychosis; 2. No capacity for criminal responsibility." Wang Leqi was stunned - "Zhang Yan succeeded in pretending to be crazy."

On November 19, 2012, an angry Wang Leqi found "Xinmin Weekly" to detail the doubts and seek support from public opinion. On the other hand, Zhang Yan’s family member, who has not accepted any media interviews so far, his second uncle Zhang Guoqiang (pseudonym adopted at the request of the interviewee) also accepted an exclusive interview with Xinmin Weekly for the first time, responding to all previous rumors one by one. Clarified and cited a large number of facts to prove that Zhang Yan was indeed in a state of mental illness at the time of the crime.

As for Zhang Yan’s various anomalies before the incident and the possible causes of his mental disorder, his family members provided some “shocking” inside information. After five months, can the truth be clarified?

After the accident, Zhang Yan was detained by the police on suspicion of "endangering public safety in a dangerous manner." Wang Leqi, the husband of the victim Wang Yanli, revealed that after Zhang Yan was detained, Zhang Yan’s family made a request for a psychiatric forensic evaluation. On August 9, Zhang Yan’s family members submitted the materials to the evaluation. Wang Leqi once protested, believing that the video recorded clearly, "She is just pretending to be crazy. The identification will only delay time and allow the murderer to linger." The police finally agreed to the request of Zhang Yan's family in accordance with the law and commissioned the Qingdao City Mental Health Commission The Judicial Appraisal Institute of the Health Center conducted an appraisal of Zhang Yan's mental state and criminal responsibility capacity at the time of the incident. Wang Leqi also expressed acceptance, "I think she (Zhang Yan) may indeed have the right in this regard. The only thing I hope for is the conclusion of the appraisal." "Be fair and equitable."

On November 12, 2012, the Criminal Police Brigade of Lanshan Branch notified Wang Leqi to get the appraisal conclusion notice and saw the words "acute transient mental illness" and "no ability to be criminally responsible". At the conclusion, Wang Leqi was stunned. "It's hard to accept. I can only say that she pretended to be crazy after killing someone, and she succeeded initially." Wang Leqi has applied to higher-level and more authoritative forensic appraisal centers in Beijing, Shanghai and other places to re-evaluate Zhang Yan's mental state.

The reporter consulted Xie Bin, deputy chairman of the Shanghai Mental Health Center and Shanghai Judicial Expert Committee on Mental Illness, about "acute transient psychosis." He explained that acute transient psychosis is a type of severe mental illness, but its onset is relatively rapid and its course is shorter than chronic mental illnesses such as schizophrenia. The course may be a few weeks or a few months. Course of disease. As for the causes of acute transient mental illness, Xie Bin explained that the causes of mental illness are very complex and it is difficult for the medical community to explain clearly. However, if the stimulus is a car accident, it does not necessarily lead to acute transient mental illness. If there is a clear inducement, such as the cause of the stimulus Most of the mental illnesses are psychogenic and post-traumatic stress disorder. Because he did not know much about the case, Xie Bin was unable to make a definite judgment on Zhang Yan's condition, but he concluded that if Zhang Yan was indeed diagnosed with acute and transient mental illness, then the car accident was probably related to this mental illness. related. "In other words, the onset of illness comes first, and the car accident comes later."

Wang Leqi does not know the professional knowledge of "acute transient mental illness", "Zhang Yan is an expert in this field, she understands." He insisted They believe that Zhang Yan is an expert in mental illness, and claim that they have visited Zhang Yan’s students, who have testified that Zhang Yan has taught courses in this area. "About a week after the incident, Zhang Yan's uncle told my mother personally that his niece was a teacher of psychiatry. He wanted to express that his niece was of high quality and would not do immoral things for no reason. He had no intention of revealing her professional background. "

Since the notice of mental appraisal conclusion given by the police to Wang Leqi was only a piece of paper, and the content was only the conclusion, Wang Leqi asked the police for the complete appraisal report issued by the appraisal center, "I want to see how such a conclusion can be made. The police revealed that the attachment contained more than 20 pages, but according to the law, they could not copy it or even read it. "What legal provisions?" Wang Leqi was confused and questioned.

Wang Leqi insisted that Zhang Yan had always been mentally normal before the incident. The two families had lived in the same community for more than ten years, and Zhang Yan had always given people the impression of being of high quality and education. "Although we don't know her very well, the basic situation is still clear. Moreover, after the incident, we interviewed a large number of people, and no one reported that she had any mental abnormalities."

For this In the appraisal conclusion, Wang Leqi raised two "doubtful points." One is that on October 26, because the appraisal conclusion was still delayed, the Wang family and CCTV reporters went to the Forensic Appraisal Institute of Qingdao Mental Health Center to urge them, “But Zhang Yan’s family actually knew immediately that the reporter had come to the appraisal center for an interview. How could they? Do you know? What's the relationship with the appraisal center?" Wang Leqi said that without this detail, they would still have some confidence in the appraisal conclusion, but they are doubtful about the impartiality of the appraisal agency.

Another "suspicious point" is that at the end of October, Wang Leqi had a long conversation with Zhang Yan's uncle for more than an hour. The latter said that he had a large number of witnesses and physical evidence, and dozens of people could testify. Yan behaved abnormally the day before the incident.

"His uncle said that Zhang Yan had four abnormalities - first, the day before the incident on June 16, Zhang Yan had abnormal behavior such as entering the men's restroom by mistake when attending a class in other places. He was taken back to Linyi by his family at 12 o'clock that night ; Second, on the morning of the incident, Zhang Yan sent his daughter to participate in a table tennis match. After getting off the car, he held his daughter and walked around three times; third, when Zhang Yan sent his daughter to the match, the driver drove her family's car. When the driver returned, Zhang Yan chased his car and went home to get his clothes. Instead of going through the main entrance, he practiced yoga on the wall and took off his shoes and threw them outside the courtyard; fourth, when Zhang Yan went down the corridor before the incident, She threw all her bankbooks and other things outside."

Wang Leqi believed that these explanations were too far-fetched and were not enough to prove that Zhang Yan was mentally disturbed before the incident. "Her behavior was probably due to her having a mistress with her husband. It was caused by a dispute." What made Wang Leqi suspicious was that before the identification conclusion was made, Zhang Yan's uncle had already told him that the large amount of evidence had been accepted by the police. "I heard that Zhang Yan's uncle took these witnesses to the criminal police team to testify. We think these testimonies lack fairness."

As for Zhang Yan's behavior, Wang Leqi insisted that it was caused by the "mistress" issue. Marriage crisis, losing control of emotions, retaliating against society, and then pretending to be crazy to avoid responsibility.

The perpetrator’s family: She had become ill before the incident and had been naked many times

The reporter then interviewed Zhang Yan’s second uncle Zhang Guoqiang (a pseudonym was used at the request of the interviewee). This is Since the incident, Zhang Yan's family members have appeared for media interviews for the first time.

Zhang Guoqiang told reporters that because Zhang Yan’s father was paralyzed in bed and his mother could not withstand the heavy blow, her husband Liu Zhen had undergone a craniotomy earlier and was introverted and poor in speech. Therefore, after Zhang Yan’s accident, He has always been responsible for related matters. "Aside from the fact that Zhang Yanzhao's accident is true, it can be said that everything told by the Wang family and the media is false, including the mistress issue, the niece running away because of a fight between the couple that day, the son-in-law being at the scene of the accident, etc. These rumors are all false. The couple has a very good relationship, and there is no such thing as a mistress."

Zhang Guoqiang said in a serious tone that the Zhang family should repent and must repent for the harm caused to the Wang family. Later, I said that my niece should bear whatever responsibilities she has, but if you want to say how bad my child is, I cannot accept it. She is really a very good and excellent child." As for why Zhang Yan behaved so abnormally, Zhang Guoqiang believes that the forensic report is an "ironclad case". "Losing control is caused by mental disorder, not emotional disorder."

Whether family members have a history of mental illness , Zhang Guoqiang revealed that Zhang Yan’s aunt had a mental disorder, and his uncle committed suicide in his 30s due to depression. He believes that Zhang Yan's mental disorder may be caused by the long-term pressure accumulated in life and work. Zhang Yan is the third eldest, with an older brother and an older sister. His father is hemiplegic, his brother-in-law has passed away, and his older sister has not yet come out of the shadow. "Zhang Yan has yet to step out of the shadows." There are two children to take care of, and the only problem with my niece-in-law Liu Zhen is that she is not very family-oriented and has no fun."

According to the second uncle's observation, Zhang Yan was not in good spirits before June 16, 2012. She has always behaved normally, although her personality has been somewhat paranoid since she was a child.

On June 12, Zhang Yan went on a business trip to attend a certain "study class" that was becoming increasingly active in the local area. The Zhang family was actually not very clear about the situation of this class. They just heard that it was a big one. A public welfare organization that cultivates people's healthy and progressive spirit and helps others, and psychologically repairs students' shortcomings. Zhang Yan was introduced to the class by Dean Zhang of his son's nursery school. Before leaving, he reassured his mother that he was studying well. During the study period, he had many phone calls with his family and everything was normal. But on June 16, the last day of study, Zhang Yan suddenly went out of his way.

Zhang Guoqiang said that on this afternoon, Zhang Yan suddenly smiled at the lecturer, imitated the movements of the students, got into a fight with someone in the women's restroom after class, and then ran to the men's restroom. "What's more serious is that there is a setting in the course where everyone closes their eyes and listens to a song. When everyone closed their eyes, she suddenly took off her clothes. At least five classmates can testify. Do you think she is mentally normal?!"

After being notified by the students, their family members rushed to the class location overnight to take Zhang Yan back to Linyi. At that time, they already found that she was not normal. She hugged her classmates and said, "I'm scared!" At first, she refused to get in the car. , did not say anything after getting in the car, and took off his shoes and threw them in the car. "I have refused to wear shoes since I got sick." Liu Zhen was not at home at the time, and Zhang Yan's mother was at home to help her take care of the child, but after returning home, Zhang Yan asked to burn his notebook. "This notebook simply records the learning content, methods, inspirational slogans, etc. The most important thing is to leave the phone numbers of my classmates. This is how I got these witnesses." Zhang Guoqiang recalled.

Zhang Yan took off her clothes and lay on the ground again. Her mother initially thought she was going to take a bath, but when she saw that her eyes were straight, she slapped her in the face and asked her daughter if she had done anything bad. , Zhang Yan returned to normal again, "Mom, I'm sorry, I'm going to take a shower."

On the morning of June 17, 2012, Zhang Yan sent his daughter to participate in a table tennis match. A friend drove him. In the car, Zhang Yan suddenly gasped for air, and his friend was shocked by this, but Zhang Yan immediately explained: "It's okay, I went crazy practicing yoga, don't you be afraid." After that, he took off his shoes and threw them into the passenger seat, naked. Put your feet on.

After returning home, Zhang Yan's behavior was not normal. He sat on the fence in front of his mother-in-law's house for five or six minutes, muttering to himself in a way that no one could hear clearly. He took off his shoes and went barefoot again. "Her mental illness is not pretending, but continues to attack." Zhang Guoqiang explained that after Zhang Yan walked back to his own home from his mother-in-law's house barefoot, he told his mother that everything in the house was fake and shouted to throw it away, but her mother could not. She had no choice but to pack these things into four bags, including bankbooks, gold and silver jewelry, cosmetics, and RMB. "She held my sister-in-law's hand again and said, Mom, hurry up, something big is going to happen to our family. Hurry up and catch up with the car in front!"

The mother thought the couple was fighting, and Zhang Yan wanted to chase him. Unexpectedly, Liu Zhen was mentally disturbed. When he went downstairs, Zhang Yan threw four bags out at once. After that, witnesses saw Zhang Yan randomly pulling the doors of several cars parked in the community. "At that time, others interpreted him as losing control of his emotions, but he was actually mentally disturbed. As soon as he got in the car, he suddenly stepped on the accelerator. In the end, it was in a racing state." Zhang Guoqiang believed that Zhang Yan could not have deliberately targeted Wang Yanli and her daughter.

After the tragedy, Zhang Yan pinched her mother’s neck twice until her neck turned purple. Fortunately, she was stopped by security in time. According to family members, when taking notes, she explained, “I didn’t pinch my mother. There was a voice in my ear telling me that there was a devil in my mother and I was trying to save her." Some witnesses said they heard Zhang Yan say, "I'm so angry!" and threatened to kill her. The mistress and the second uncle said that he was not very clear about this. The second uncle introduced that the outside world saw Zhang Yan naked in the video, blocking the rescue and snatching the injured child. In fact, the video only recorded a fragment of the incident. After that, she ran naked to the house of another resident with whom she had a close personal relationship. The male head of the family was at home. He was very embarrassed about this. He found clothes to wrap Zhang Yan's body and comfort her. But at this time, Zhang Yan pounced on the child of the family and almost strangled the child to death.

Investigation: Mysterious "Study Class"

After the accident, because Zhang Yan did not have normal emotional reactions, the Zhang family realized that Zhang Yan might have a mental problem. In the afternoon, they sent Zhang Yan to the local mental hospital in Linyi. At noon the next day, Zhang Yan was taken away by the police. The doctor wrote three items on the diagnosis and treatment book: emergency response syndrome, assisting the police in discharge investigation, and recommending further systematic treatment. According to family members, after Zhang Yan was taken to the police station, she was relieved and told her family members who were taking care of her that it was a good place and that no kid could get in, so she fell asleep.

Zhang Yan was detained in the detention center. For five months, her family members had not seen her and did not know her mental condition. They had applied for Zhang Yan to receive treatment, but the police required them to issue corresponding documents. evidence. "We did not hire a lawyer, but we did consult one, but the cost was terrifying." The Zhang family endured tremendous mental pressure. Faced with verbal and written criticism on the Internet, the Zhang family chose to remain silent and refused to accept any interviews.

So, what kind of "study class" did Zhang Yan attend, what kind of experience and performance did she have there, and how are these related to her acute transient mental illness? This has become the biggest mystery in the minds of the Zhang family.

According to the clues provided by the Zhang family, the reporter found that this "study class" was actually organized by a local business management consulting company in Linyi. After checking the company's website, the reporter found that there was an "instructor introduction" in a prominent position. , click on the link and see content such as "Nationally certified system arrangement instructor, simple and fast physical and mental positive therapy practitioner, life growth coach..." and other contents.

What Zhang Yan participated in should be "leadership quality training", and the leadership quality training course claims that through three stages of experiential training: self-discovery, self-transcendence, and achieving personal and team goals, the students' Comprehensive quality and leadership skills are improved. The number of days of the course is 4 days and 3 nights for the first stage, 5 days and 4 nights for the second stage, and 108 days for the third stage.

The reporter found an unnamed student who was in the same period as Zhang Yan. He revealed that Zhang Yan participated in the second phase of training, but the core information such as the content and methods of the training was unknown to the student. He refused to disclose, but just told reporters that Zhang Yan has been "not bubbling" in the process of "discovering himself" and "transcending himself". The so-called "no bubbling" means that Zhang Yan does not open up the depths of her soul like the other nearly 70 students, so the instructor cannot "connect" and enlighten her. Other students also tried to help her "open", but failed. As for the method of help, this student also refused to disclose.

During the training period, the students slept very short every day and did not sleep at all on the last night. This is also a course model used by similar training institutions in China to exercise will. However, he definitely told reporters that in the process of self-discovery and self-transcendence, there is no way to challenge the moral or legal bottom line. On the afternoon of the 16th, Zhang Yan showed a series of mental disorder behaviors such as stripping naked, giggling, and entering the men's room. This student witnessed it with his own eyes, but he believed that Zhang Yan's disorder had nothing to do with the class because no one else had any problems. Successfully achieved "transcending oneself".

Zhang Guoqiang also investigated the "study class" afterwards and found that this organization had indeed organized members to carry out charity activities in Linyi area many times, and some of the activities even included local leaders in Linyi. . He doubted whether the training methods and motivational methods of the class were overloaded, but unfortunately, the students he came into contact with were very secretive about this. "So many people said after participating in the study that their will became stronger and nothing happened, but Zhang Yan? I really can't explain it.

”

On the afternoon of November 19, 2012, Wang Le went to the Linyi City Public Security Bureau to continue to ask for a complete appraisal report. The police focused on introducing to him Zhang Yan’s participation in the “study class” before the incident and planned Investigating the "study class".

Wang Leqi was very surprised when the reporter introduced the Zhang family's statement to him that evening. I found a friend who had studied in the "study class" and moved him with his tragic statement. This friend believed that Zhang Yan taking off his clothes in the study class was not an abnormal behavior, because the class's self-transcendence curriculum included Content - take off clothes, the instructors are both male and female, and ask the male and female students to do all the things they usually dare not do, such as stripping naked, dancing, hugging each other, and "communicating" with the instructor. The more you dare to "open up", the more you can transcend. Self.

As for the specific content of "opening" and "communication", the student did not want to disclose it, and suggested that Wang Leqi can sign up to study on his own if he is interested, but the registration is subject to strict qualification review, and the instructor will meet during the study process. Students’ cellphones were confiscated, and students were not allowed to take photos or videos. “When the training entered the third stage, students were asked to go to the streets to raise funds. Hundreds of thousands of yuan were collected in a short period of time. After collecting 5 million yuan, 3 million yuan was used for charity donations, and 2 million yuan was used for charity. Yuan is reserved for management fees. "Wang Leqi believes that this organization is extremely mysterious to the outside world and has serious problems.

However, Wang Leqi still insists on going to an appraisal agency he trusts to re-evaluate whether Zhang Yan is really sick.

"If I am really sick, I would also like to find out what is the connection with that study class? Who should be responsible for this tragedy?"