Why is Harbin’s economy developing so slowly?

I think the answer above is evasive and emphasizes objective reasons a bit too much. National policies will only add icing on the cake and will not provide you with help when you need it. Harbin is not special, so there is no reason for people to take you seriously. To strike iron, you have to be strong yourself. Harbin lags behind not just in the slightest, but in the overall business environment, the government's ability to govern, the overall quality and salary levels of personnel, and the activity of industrial industries. There is a huge gap between them and developed areas. The conditions in Harbin are so poor in all aspects, so why should the country put so much effort into supporting you? Therefore, if economic development is to be slow, we must first look for the reasons within ourselves. The government and banks should support the development of small and medium-sized enterprises and should not always focus on the so-called large state-owned enterprises. The prosperity of a region cannot be driven by just a few large enterprises. Moreover, even the few large state-owned enterprises in Harbin have very low competitiveness compared with their counterparts outside the province due to rigid systems. The second is to improve the business environment and improve the legal system. Harbin's legal system is very backward in the country. Because of social environment issues, I didn’t ask to believe in the law. Everyone who does business in Harbin knows this. A contract is just a piece of waste paper. No one takes the law seriously at all. This leads to the rampant unspoken rules in social life. This virtually increases operating costs and risks. Those who do business do not think about how to make the business bigger, but try every means to find a big backer to prevent being ripped off by various functional departments and blackmailed by members of the public. How can a small business grow big in such a business environment? Therefore, many talented people in Harbin are forced to move away to start businesses or invest in other places. Even if you want to work part-time, Harbin is not a qualified city. The average salary level is ridiculously low, and private company owners are doing their best to exploit their employees because their companies are struggling to survive. Whether it is a large company or a small company, cases of wage arrears, wage deductions and even wage misappropriation abound. It is also the people of Harbin who themselves are not up to par. The people of Harbin are absolutely among the best in the country in their ability to endure oppression from others. One of the reasons is because Harbin people love face. This is also the biggest weakness of Harbin people. Protecting their own rights seems unthinkable to them. Anyone who does this is tantamount to admitting that they have been bullied. Being bullied is the same as being incompetent in the eyes of Harbin people. It's very embarrassing. Therefore, even if their rights are violated and trampled on, many people will still knock out their teeth and swallow it in their stomachs. I will not argue with the relevant departments. Keeping peace is a common practice of Harbin people when dealing with injustice. Doing so leads to good people being bullied and evil people becoming arrogant in society. This is also the reason why many outsiders feel that Harbin people are relatively rough. Because everyone knows it pays to be a villain here. When Harbin people arrived in a city with a relatively healthy social environment, they immediately became polite. How much has Harbin's economy suffered invisibly due to such an unhealthy social atmosphere? These are only some of the reasons for Harbin's economic backwardness. This question is a big one, so I will give a general answer and analyze the reasons. I am a person who has business in Harbin and other places. I usually go to places where I come into contact with a lot of outsiders. The above are my thoughts on the city of Harbin based on my own experience. My starting point is reflection rather than bragging. Hope it helps.