Why did the old man and the nanny get married for 4 days and only separated in March and were transferred away from their savings?

A disabled old man in Shaoguan, Guangdong Province, after his children hired a nanny who was only in his forties to take care of him, he "flashed marriage" after only four days of acquaintance. After the marriage, after the husband's savings of more than 26, yuan were transferred away by his wife, the once "hot" feelings between the two sides quickly cooled down. After the old man was sent to a nursing home by his wife, she turned a blind eye to him. In a rage, the old man filed a divorce lawsuit and asked the other party to return his life savings. At present, the property dispute case has been concluded according to law, and Shaoguan Intermediate People's Court sentenced the defendant Liao to return the plaintiff Li for more than 17, yuan.

After the old man showed her passbook, she offered to get married.

Li, an 8-year-old man, used to be a worker in a mining bureau. In August 196, an accident occurred at work, which resulted in severe head trauma, disability of the right lower limb, serious brain and intelligence damage, and long-term inability to take care of himself. He was identified as a first-class disability. Because Li has no self-care ability, on December 17, 215, two daughters hired Liao, a woman who was only in her 4 s at that time, as a nanny to take care of the elderly at home in order to take care of her father.

On the second day after Liao arrived at Li's home, he learned that Li was widowed and lived alone, and his three children were not around. At the same time, he asked the plaintiff about his personal economic situation. Because Li was completely blind in one eye and couldn't see clearly, he showed all his bankbooks to the nanny. At this time, Liao actually offered to marry Li.

Li believes that Liao is a native of Hunan province and speaks the same language, so without telling his children, the two parties actually registered their marriage only four days after they met each other. On the night of marriage registration, Liao and her husband discussed that your eyes were not clear and your thinking was hindered. In order to prevent his children from taking away their deposits, they mobilized her husband to transfer all the deposits to his own name and take charge of the family economy by himself.

Without much consideration, on December 22 and 23, 215, Li went through the deposit transfer formalities in the bank for two consecutive days. In the process of handling, the two daughters found that Liao transferred his father's bank deposit to his account. On the same day, the two daughters reported the case to the public security organ, but the public security organ believed that Li and Liao were legal couples, which belonged to the civil category and would not be accepted. After that, according to the intention of the old man, the staff of the bank transferred all the remaining deposits of the old man to Liao's account except for withdrawing some cash.

After getting all the savings of the elderly, Liao bought pension insurance for himself, totaling about 16, yuan, without her husband's consent, and took away more than 3, yuan in cash from Li. After the old man reflected the above situation to his children, the two daughters angrily asked their stepmother about their father's property.

Liao wrote two promises on December 3, 215, which read as follows: "I married Li myself, and after marriage, Li voluntarily took 15, yuan to buy me old-age insurance, leaving 6, yuan. I promise to take care of Li's life in the future, not to give my family money, not to my family, and not to mention divorce again. If I don't abide by it, I will transfer Li's money back to him." "I am Liao. After I got married with Li, my property was in my name. I will be responsible for Li's illness and death in the future."

"Young and Old Match" separated after only three months of marriage

After Liao took control of Li's property, he gradually became very indifferent to the elderly and often made things difficult for the elderly. The two sides had to start separating on March 8, 216, and she began to ignore her husband's life. On March 25, 216, after Liao sent her husband to a nursing home in Wujiang District, Shaoguan City, she left him and ignored him. The old man's daughter asked Liao to fulfill the responsibility of being a wife, but she didn't even listen to the phone or return the text messages.

The old man thought that Liao's behavior had caused a great blow to his spirit, and at the same time violated her earlier promise, so he filed a divorce lawsuit with Wujiang District People's Court and was granted. At the same time, the old man believes that the money transferred from Liao's bank account, the cash withdrawn and the funds for purchasing personal insurance during the marriage are all his personal pre-marital property, and the defendant should return them according to the law.

Defendant Liao argued in court that before the two parties registered for marriage, Li never mentioned that the previous deposits belonged to pre-marital property and should be used by both parties. It was Li who voluntarily transferred the deposit to his account, not himself. She only bought old-age insurance, and it was not used for other purposes. The plaintiff insured the defendant as a husband's concern and responsibility for his wife.

She also said that the promise she had written before was written under the pressure and intimidation of Li's family. In order to get rid of the intimidation of Li's family, she had given the old man's passbook to his children, so she didn't take all the old man's deposits. She also said that the dissolution of her marriage was caused by the old man's daughter. She agreed to divorce only when there was no other way. Therefore, I requested to dismiss Li' s claim.

court: only the normal expenses of the family are deducted, and the balance is returned

Wujiang court held that there was no special agreement on property between the original and the defendant, and the income of each party after marriage was used for the husband and wife to live together. Li handed over the pre-marital deposit to the defendant as a voluntary punishment for all personal property, and there was no coercion or mental confusion. The two are husband and wife, and Li can foresee that Liao may dispose of the above deposit but still give it to Liao, and the two people will have property consumption after marriage, so Li's behavior should be regarded as his voluntary use of the pre-marital deposit for the married couple.

In this case, Li handed over the property to Liao on the premise of maintaining the marital relationship between the two parties, combined with the two Promises written by the defendant and the recorded materials submitted by Li during the trial. In the case that the marriage relationship between the two parties has been dissolved, the defendant should return the plaintiff's personal property before marriage after deducting the reasonable expenses in her life after marriage.

since the two parties started to live apart from each other on March 8, 216, they only lived together for more than two months, and during this period, they didn't buy large items together. Moreover, there is no evidence to prove that the insurance purchased by the defendant Liao was approved by the plaintiff, so the insurance fee should not be deducted from the same expenses, and the court only deducted 1, yuan from the normal family expenses recognized by Li during this period. In addition, because Li has got back the fixed deposit book after March 8, 216, and he also believes that there are still 8, yuan in the deposit book, the court found that the 8, yuan should also be deducted in this case. In summary, the defendant Liao should return 174, yuan to the plaintiff Li.

after the first-instance judgment, Liao refused to accept it and appealed to Shaoguan Intermediate People's Court. The second-instance judgment of Shaoguan Intermediate People's Court rejected the defendant's appeal and upheld the original judgment.

if you get the money, you don't care. You must get it back.