Xinyang or Zhumadian, which city develops better?

To tell the truth, the economies of Xinyang and Zhumadian are not very good in Henan, but we can compare these two cities in many ways.

Basic information: Xinyang has a total area of 18925 square kilometers, governs two districts and eight counties, and has a population of 8.75 million, but the resident population is only over 6 million. It can be said that the population loss is extremely serious. Zhumadian has a total area of10.5 million square kilometers, one district and nine counties, with a total population of 8 million and a permanent population of only over 6 million. It can be said that the profiles of the two places are very similar.

Economic potential: Although the two cities are large in size and population, their gdp is not high. Xinyang ranked eighth with 203.4 billion yuan, and Zhumadian ranked tenth with 654.38+08 billion yuan. However, Zhumadian has a slightly better geographical location, good transportation, east-west cooperation and a good historical foundation. Selected as one of the "Top Ten Most Potential Tourist Destinations", it can be said that it has great potential. Xinyang is not far behind. In 20 17, it was selected as one of the top 50 cities with the most investment potential in China. You should know that Zhengzhou and Xinyang are the only two cities in Henan, and Xinyang has many city business cards, and Maojian, Regan Noodles and Xinyang are far more famous than Zhumadian.

In fact, I am optimistic about the development of Xinyang, because Xinyang has many names, such as the top ten livable cities in China, the most happy city, the excellent city of toilet revolution, the national health city and so on. I like the beautiful scenery and delicious snacks in Xinyang. Therefore, I support Xinyang more than Zhumadian.

I am from Zhumadian. Let me also say a few words.

In terms of population, Xinyang's registered population and permanent population have overwhelmed Zhumadian. Xinyang's population advantage is more obvious.

In terms of environment, Xinyang city has mountains, waters and plains, outstanding people and outstanding land, and the south-central part is a veritable south of the Yangtze River, a land of plenty! The southwest of Zhumadian is a mountainous area, and other places are endless plains. Compared with Xinyang, water resources are relatively scarce (caused by the interception of transit water by reservoirs in northwest Henan, but the overall situation is still far better than that in northern Henan).

Culturally speaking, the two places have long belonged to Runing House, and there are great similarities in culture and blood relationship. The borders of the two cities are both near the Huaihe River and on the north-south dividing line, so the two cities have obvious north-south transition phenomena in climate and culture. In most areas of Zhumadian, tofu is sweet, but there is a spicy soup with noodles, mainly pasta; In Xinyang, there are Hui Mian and Hu Spicy Soup in the north, and Regan Noodles in the south-central part is gradually increasing. The food is mainly rice, and the menu is richer than Zhumadian.

When I was a child, I often heard adults say, "Nanxiang"! Later, I learned that this "Nanxiang" refers to Xinyang. At that time, everyone thought Xinyang's economy was quite good, much better than Zhumadian. At that time, my junior high school teacher was from Xinyang Mall. I often said that their economy was much better than ours, so that his old father would bring him a bag of rice when he came to Pingyao to see her. It sounded exaggerated. But we can also feel the economic gap between the two places. At this stage, I feel that Xinyang's economy is comparable to Zhumadian's, because everyone has gone out to work, so everyone has the same opportunities, and the income gap should not be too big. As for the local economy, it is not good!

If we only consider the urban construction in two areas, we can directly compare them with graphs:

Xinyang City:

Zhumadian City:

From the first impression, compared with these two cities, Xinyang urban area should be larger. However, it can be clearly seen that the urban framework of Zhumadian North and South has also been opened. However, due to the natural conditions of Xinyang, Xinyang is definitely better in livability.

However, Xinyang also has shortcomings. What is this? It's just that Xinyang is too far to the west, and many people in the eastern part of China have never even been to Xinyang, so it's hard to get impetus from Xinyang. Fortunately, the integration of Huang and Guang has been put forward, otherwise it is estimated that it is difficult to develop the eastern part of Xinyang. Zhumadian city is relatively medium, which can well promote the development of surrounding counties and cities.

For the future development, I am still optimistic about Xinyang, because Xinyang has good mountains and rivers and beautiful scenery! Food culture is better and more famous than Zhumadian. Xinyang people are the only group in Henan who can open restaurants to the whole country, and the only group who dares to hang "Henan cuisine". They just ate Gushi goose yesterday. It was really delicious!

Speaking of Xinyang and Zhumadian, the changes in recent years are still quite great, and the development is also fruitful. Under the background of southern Henan, it is inevitable that everyone wants to ask, compare and know which city is better developed. Today I will simply share it with you.

First of all, let's cut to the chase. It is undeniable that Zhumadian has developed slightly better than Xinyang in recent years. Urban construction and industrial progress are on the rise. Although Xinyang is also developing at the same time, Zhumadian has made greater progress in comparison. Let's analyze it in detail.

Xinyang Zhumadian belongs to the south of Henan Province. When New China was founded, it was under the exclusive jurisdiction of Xinyang City. Later, at 1965, the letter was divided and ruled, forming today's situation. In the early years, the development of Xinyang was much better than that of Zhumadian. The original political and cultural center of Zhumadian was mainly concentrated in today's runan county. Xinyang was a county-level city in the early days of the founding of the People's Republic of China, and its foundation was superior to Zhumadian.

Furthermore, from the economic rankings in previous years, we can see that Xinyang's economic aggregate was higher than Zhumadian's in previous years, but in recent years, with the development of reform and opening up and the cooperation of Qi Xin in Zhumadian, the economy is also quietly rising. In the economic ranking of the first three quarters of this year, Zhumadian surpassed Xinyang for the first time (20 17, the GDP of Xinyang in the first three quarters was the ninth, and Zhumadian was the tenth).

In terms of urban construction, I personally think Zhumadian is slightly better than Xinyang. Among them, public transport services, information coverage, and new technology applications are faster than Xinyang and even other cities in Henan. In terms of city honor, Zhumadian leads Xinyang. In addition to some national health cities and excellent tourist cities, Zhumadian has also won the honorary title of national civilized city and national forest city. These may seem to be some titles, but the annual activities to create a civilized city are not only accepted, but also improve the overall comprehensive quality of the city.

Of course, Xinyang is better than Zhumadian, but in general, Zhumadian has made greater and more obvious progress in recent years. So I personally think that Zhumadian is developing better.

Personally, on the whole, Zhumadian is stronger than Xinyang now, and its development prospect is better than Xinyang.

It is said that Xinyang has good water, but you don't know how serious the water pollution in Xinyang has been in recent years. Urban inland rivers are basically the lowest in the province, and they are fined every year for water. A few days ago, Huangchuan was informed by the Ministry of Environmental Protection, and Qiao Xinjiang immediately went to Huangchuan for investigation. Now the leaders of the county party committee and county government of Huangchuan Mall are all in informed criticism. In terms of water, except the total amount of water resources, there are more reservoirs than Zhumadian. Xinyang lags far behind Zhumadian in water environmental protection.

In terms of air, Xinyang and Zhumadian have bonuses every year (several cities in the north have penalties). Comparatively speaking, Xinyang's air is indeed better than Zhumadian's, but the gap is not big.

In terms of cities, the framework of Xinyang is bigger now, because the Shihe Heping Bridge urban area is connected together, plus Yangshan New District and Industrial City, the urban area is indeed bigger than Zhumadian. But the quality of urban construction in Zhumadian is poor. Zhumadian city construction has been too fierce in recent years. Planning and construction standards are much higher than Xinyang. The road is very wide and beautiful. There are too many rules for pedestrians and vehicles than Xinyang. Because Zhumadian is a national civilized city, Xinyang won't be available in five years. And if the integration of the resident and Sui is successful, Xinyang can't catch up. Xinyang New Fifth Avenue was not opened to traffic in 7.8 years, and a Siyi Road overpass can be widened for more than 2 years. It took several years for several bridges above Shihe River to have a little hope. 107 and 3 12 pass through the city, especially 107 is basically in the city center. Xinyang East-West North-South Road meets, and the traffic advantage is really better.

In terms of industry, it is stronger than Xinyang, and there are more large enterprises than Xinyang.

In agriculture, it is half a catty.

In terms of tourism, Xinyang does have many resource advantages, but it has lagged behind Zhumadian in recent years. Chaya mountain was rated as 5A, but Xinyang had none.

One more thing, Xinyang people are arrogant and like to look down on others. They should go out more often.

A little thought may be incomplete [laughter]

The two cities belong to the same province, both of which are general prefecture-level cities, so it is relatively difficult to make a big deviation. Generally speaking, Xinyang is slightly better than Zhumadian.

From the perspective of regional economy

In 20 17, Xinyang's annual GDP was 222.655 billion yuan, and its annual per capita GDP was 34.528 yuan. Zhumadian's annual GDP is 200.264 billion yuan, and its per capita GDP is 32,565 yuan. From the perspective of total amount and per capita, there is little difference between the two cities, and Xinyang is slightly ahead.

As far as population is concerned,

At the end of 20 17, Xinyang had a total population of 8,805,300, including 6,453,600 permanent residents. At the end of 20 17, Zhumadian had a total population of 80 17400 and a permanent population of 6 15500. Both cities have a net outflow of population, which reflects that the two regions cannot provide attractive jobs.

In terms of tourism

Xinyang received 30.567 million tourists in 20 17, including 30.55 million domestic tourists, and the total tourism revenue was 65.438+09.907 billion yuan. In 20 17, Zhumadian received 319.73 million domestic tourists, including 3 1953 10000 domestic tourists, and the total tourism revenue was184.56 million yuan.

higher education

In 20 17, there were 5 colleges and universities in Xinyang with 27,300 students, 86,400 students and 28,900 graduates. There are 3 universities in Zhumadian, with 8700 students, 26200 students and 6500 graduates. Xinyang has more advantages than Zhumadian in this respect.

Generally speaking, they are almost as bad as each other. They are both from China. He is my brother. Who has more meat than who?

No matter who develops well, the two cities have their own advantages. Zhumadian is rich in mineral resources, with rutile ore reserves ranking first in China, coal, iron and oil with good quality and large reserves. With this advantage and geographical location, we can consider developing in the direction of industry. Xinyang is located in the south and has superior natural resources. It is known as the "land of plenty" in Henan, and wetland parks abound. In addition, Xinyang has a unique diet, which is quite distinctive in Henan and even the whole country, and Xinyang Maojian tea is even more famous. I think Xinyang will develop the tertiary industry and then drive the overall economic development.

As for the population, it is 67 million. What's the use? I'm afraid nearly half of the people have gone out to work. So don't care who is good and who is bad. The most important thing is to seize the new opportunity and follow a development path that suits you according to the actual situation, so as to improve your economic strength as soon as possible.

When local people don't want to go out to make a living, when they really develop, don't live up to their good resources.

In fact, Xinyang City and Zhumadian City are similar, both in the middle reaches of our province. In terms of population, Zhumadian City is still higher than Xinyang City, but in terms of current economic aggregate, Xinyang City is still higher than Zhumadian. Zhumadian is mainly inconvenient in transportation and a big agricultural city.

For example, Xinyang, it is said that agriculture is underdeveloped, but industry is also not good, and Xinyang is the city with the most serious population loss among prefecture-level cities in Henan Province. I think there should be many Xinyang people working in Wuhan. After all, compared with Zhengzhou and Wuhan, Xinyang is closer to Wuhan, and the development of Wuhan is quite good.

However, from the future, I am still optimistic about Zhumadian, because in the future development, such as traffic location, enterprises will be promoted quickly, but the demographic dividend advantage is really difficult to change, and the population of Zhumadian is higher than Xinyang. Zhumadian is a typical plain area, so the future of Zhumadian is immeasurable.

Although I am from Queshan, Zhumadian, my home is closer to Minggang Town, Xinyang. I think the speed and scale of discovery in Xinyang City are faster and larger than that in Zhumadian. Xinyang Minggang high-speed railway station is only about 10 km from my home. Queshan Lixin Store Airport has been renamed Xinyang Airport. It is said that the flight was opened in August this year, but it was driven by the development of Xinyang. This is really ironic. Zhumadian needs to refuel.

I am from Xinyang, and my home is in Yangshan New District, Xinyang. 15 moved to Zhumadian, working in the urban-rural integration demonstration zone (high-speed rail business circle). Aside from the official data, Zhumadian has really changed a lot since 20 16, and the city is much cleaner (although there is still a layer of dust after parking for a day), but it is really much better than before. The urban framework has been greatly expanded, urban planning is advanced, traffic management is standardized, and public service construction has also developed rapidly. On the other hand, Xinyang has not changed for several years. The old city has been closed, and the new city has not changed much. Xinyang has been delayed a lot. Of course, Xinyang is undoubtedly superior to Zhumadian in this natural condition. Xinyang should consider the reasons!

Personal point of view. Don't spray if you don't like it personally. I think Xinyang will develop much better than Zhumadian. Although I haven't seen anything recently, what's special about Xinyang compared with Zhumadian? But we can't ignore that Xinyang's tea and chestnuts enjoy a high reputation in China and even the world. There are many places of interest in Zhumadian, but it is not perfect because of its geographical location, industrial development and supporting facilities for its corresponding residents. My home is close to Zhumadian and not far from Xinyang. Maybe foreign monks can recite scriptures. Personally, it is still a belief. In the future development, you will be a little ahead of Zhumadian, because after all, Henan is a big agricultural province, and Zhumadian's geographical location is relatively plain, which may be more about developing agriculture and animal husbandry. Relatively speaking, the goal of industrial and commercial development is not clear.