Helping the elderly leads to the death of the elderly.

Should we get up after the old man falls?

I think this discussion is necessary. Respecting the old and caring for the young, saving the wounded and saving the dying, has always been a fine tradition of our country. No one will grow old without old people.

With the media exposure of Peng Yu case and many other cases that helped the fallen elderly to do good deeds, they were falsely accused by the elderly as the perpetrators, and even awarded huge compensation by the court on the grounds of "common sense judgment" and other logical reasoning. More and more people are afraid of helping the fallen elderly.

A little effort may bring endless trouble. Social morality and traditional morality are gradually lost in our hesitant eyes.

When the whole society, the public and the media are hotly discussing whether the fallen elderly should be helped, it has actually proved that the public morality of this society has gone bankrupt to some extent. Obviously, as a social person, it seems that no one can answer this question.

The unscrupulous Nanjing and Tianjin judges, as well as punishing the elderly who falsely accused Peng Yu, should be condemned, but will the onlookers in Farewell be condemned by morality, justice and conscience?

After Li Laohan, an 88-year-old man from Wuhan, fell down at the entrance of the food market less than 100 meters away from home, many onlookers were afraid to lend a helping hand. In the end, the event that the old man died of nasal bleeding blocking the respiratory tract shocked the whole society. The public's indifference and insensitivity to the fall of the elderly should be reviewed by the whole society and even everyone. I used to think that it was not a problem whether the elderly should be helped or not, but now it has really become a big problem. Cases like Nanjing judge and Wuhan old man are not common phenomena, but the social reality they reflect is very severe.

When we discuss whether the fallen elderly should be helped, we are not deliberately exaggerating the seriousness of the problem, but questioning the decline of social morality and values, because similar indifference and ruthlessness not only happen to the fallen elderly, but also many other cases, such as the stories of heroes bleeding and tears, such as the crying of "jumping" when watching people commit suicide by jumping off a building, such as the normal state that passengers on buses turn a blind eye to thieves, and so on.

Since the nanjing old lady xu incident, China began to enter the period of national moral decay and began to disintegrate the morality of China people. People like Mrs. Xu began to be unscrupulous, with legal support, and they could get huge returns without any cost. Peng Yu paid too high a price, so he began to be indifferent to the sympathy of Chinese people and played down the feelings between people. Later, a series of events, such as fishing law enforcement, completely numbed people's sympathy, leading to a state of mind that had nothing to do with themselves and hung high, which caused the octogenarian to fall to the ground for more than 1 hour, and no one dared to lend a helping hand. I'm sure that most of the onlookers were kind people before, but no one can afford the huge price. Can you say that people are indifferent?

Where are many flies? Are they rubbish or flies?

Argumentation lacks hierarchy and discourse language has no appeal.

Article 1: Should the old man be helped when he falls?

Should the old man be helped when he falls?

Abstract: There are frequent incidents of anti-extortion to help the fallen elderly, and netizens have different opinions on this. Will the fallen old man be helped or not? This paper first introduces the attitude of netizens, then expounds the viewpoint of "the gang" and puts forward some suggestions.

Keywords: the old man fell; Blackmail; Ask for help; Charity action

Should the old man be helped when he falls? In the past, the answer to this question was of course "help", but now people are gradually hesitating about it. Nanjing Peng Yu case, Henan Zhengzhou Li Kaiqiang case, etc. It has dealt a blow to kind people, but it is not uncommon for old people to fall to the ground and be looked on coldly.

Shanxi News Network reported such a thing: a 60-year-old man was lying on the ice next to the traffic post of Xiqi Road, Xinfu District, Fushun City. The old man was surrounded by more than 20 passers-by. You gave advice to the old man who fell to the ground, but no one came forward to help him, and the old man refused to be called "120"110 ". The situation has been deadlocked. Later, a young auxiliary police officer helped solve the problem. The auxiliary police officer later said in an interview: "To be honest, I am not afraid of anything in this police uniform. If I take off this police uniform, I dare not help. "

Most people understand the inaction of onlookers. The netizen simply said, "I can call 120 for him, but I won't help him." Doing more is better than doing less. In case you are wrong, you will be in big trouble. " This survey initiated by Tencent. Com also shows that 62.54% of netizens choose "never, for fear of getting into trouble", 33.45% of netizens think that they should judge rationally before making a decision, and only 4.0 1% of netizens think that they should help the elderly and think that "this is the minimum public morality".

Helping others, respecting the old and loving the young are the traditional virtues of the Chinese nation. Unfortunately, an old man fell to the ground and the people around him were indifferent. In fact, there are many things to help the elderly, but not many. There are people in the street who help the old man who fell down and get thanks. It's just that the media ignored these good things and only reported the framed people and things vigorously. Once this kind of incident happens, it spreads widely, people's kindness is gradually worn away, and they are wary of the fallen old people. Netizen "Antarctic Warmth" said: "It is possible to be blackmailed, but that is a very small number, and at most one person in 10 is blackmailed! How can we give up helping an old man for a one-tenth chance? "

On the Spring Festival Evening of 20 14 Year of the Horse, the essay "Help or Not" once again "fired" this sharp question. Hao Jian, a kind young man, wanted to help his aunt who fell, but she misunderstood him. A story of crying and laughing begins like this. But in the end, a policeman testified for Hao Jian, and Hao Jian was thanked. It can be seen that it is not difficult to help the old man, let alone a bad thing.

On the other hand, the physical condition of the elderly is generally not optimistic, and there is a possibility of fracture when they fall. There are also old people who fall down not because they walk carelessly, but because they suddenly get sick. If you don't help at this time, the consequences may be very serious. Imagine that when the old man is in severe pain, everyone around him is just talking, and no one gives a helping hand. How chilling it is for the old man! How cold the world will become! If you lend a helping hand, you will not only help an injured old man, but also contribute to the warmth of society.

If you are afraid of being misunderstood, you can ask the nearby police for help or ask passers-by to testify. If it is safer, you can also let others take pictures of the process with your mobile phone as evidence to protect yourself. Visible, the old man fell, as long as the method is proper, still can help. The question "Should the old man be helped when he falls down" is not difficult to answer. .

The poet Ji Bolun once said: "A great man has two hearts: one is a bleeding heart and the other is a tolerant heart." Have you ever bought a fake and never bought anything again? In other words, we can't question the light and avoid it, because we are deceived by darkness in the pursuit of light. If there is a shadow in front of you, it means there is sunshine behind you. In life, we should not just

Pay attention to the darkness in front of you and ignore the light behind you; You can't refuse or even be afraid to help someone who fell down just because he was kind enough to help him.

There is also an old saying: "Old people are old, young people are young, and young people are young." On this issue, if your elders fall, of course you will help them, so you should also help others' elders fall. You once helped an old man who fell, and later onlookers will help him, and more and more people will do so. When others are slandered, witnesses should boldly stand up and testify, help those who do good deeds, promote the transmission of good deeds, and let good people no longer have "troubles." Please help the old man who fell. We should make "help" a good act of kindness, not a sharp problem.

Article 2: Should the old man be helped when he falls?

Should the old man be helped when he falls?

In Dazhou, Jiang fell to the ground and suffered a comminuted fracture at the root of his thigh. After the mother-in-law fell, she grabbed the hand of a 9-year-old child. The child's family said that the child is going to help the elderly; Jiang said that three children knocked themselves down.

165438+1October 2 1

Parents call the police to file a case for fraud.

One of the children's family, Mr. Changjiang, went to Nanwai Town Police Station and called the police in the name of extortion. The police station confirmed that the police filed a case for fraud.

165438+1October 22nd

Three people testified and the mother-in-law and son were detained.

Dachuan Branch of Dazhou Public Security Bureau reported through the official Weibo that Jiang Popo fell by herself, which was confirmed by three witnesses. Due to extortion, the public security organs imposed administrative detention and fines on Jiang Popo and her son. However, considering that Jiang's mother-in-law is over 70 years old, administrative detention will not be carried out according to law.

165438+ October 23rd

To apply for reconsideration, my mother-in-law swore not to lie.

The old man still insists that he was knocked down by a child. She felt very wronged and even swore: "If I tell a lie, my family will die." Faced with the decision of the public security organ, the elderly people expressed dissatisfaction and will apply for reconsideration.

On June 15 this year, Jiang fell to the ground near Zhengnan Garden in Dazhou City, causing a comminuted fracture of the thigh root. After falling, mother-in-law Jiang grabbed a 9-year-old child's hand. The child said that he rushed to help the old man, but he was framed. Jiang said that three children knocked themselves down. Due to extortion, the local public security organs gave Jiang Popo and her son administrative detention, fines and other penalties (Chengdu Business Daily recently reported continuously).

Yesterday, the Chengdu Business Daily reporter learned from the families of the three children that they were quite satisfied with the handling by the public security organs and finally cleared the children. "There are a lot of media to interview us these two days, and I feel very tired." According to Mr. Yu, a parent, since the truth of the incident came out, the media all over the country have focused on their families. "Now the child is in good condition and alive and kicking every day." According to the child's family, because there were too many media interviews, I was worried about the child's inner expansion and refused some media interviews. "We also want to live a quiet life and hope that this matter will calm down and return to normal life."

At the same time, Jiang Popo's family is also busy being interviewed by the media. The family still insists that the old man was knocked down by a child. Yesterday, 74-year-old mother-in-law Jiang was interviewed by a TV station and still said that the child knocked her down. During the interview, Jiang's mother-in-law was also a little excited and knelt down to a TV reporter and said, "I am wronged." When the old man was not completely kneeling on the ground, the reporter quickly helped him up.

"The administrative reconsideration procedure must go, but I am too busy today to go." Jiang Popo's grandson said that they would take legal channels and ask lawyers to help them collect evidence and help defend their rights. At 9 o'clock last night, Jiang's family told Chengdu Business Daily that Wang Fuen, a lawyer of Sichuan Strait Law Firm, had contacted them and the lawyer expressed his willingness.

They collected some evidence and helped them for free. "Willing to accept rights protection, you need to discuss with your family before deciding."

Faith >>

At any time, when paying attention to the controversial case of "false accusation", we must not forget that "the most beautiful" is far more than "false accusation".

Courage >; & gt

If you pay too much attention to the results when someone needs help, or even worry about whether you will be accused, you will definitely miss the best rescue opportunity.

Wisdom >; & gt

If you don't have professional rescue knowledge, you may wish to turn to professional institutions and use communication equipment.

Xinhua news agency:

Don't let "good deeds be blackmailed"

The decision of administrative punishment made by the police has made the incident of an old man falling from a building in Dazhou, Sichuan Province have a preliminary result, but the incident itself and even the public's attention are far from over.

There is no doubt that restoring the truth of the incident and clarifying right and wrong are crucial to maintaining social fairness and justice. From the early cases of Peng Yu and Xu Yunhe to Dazhou, people pay attention to the results, hoping that those who do good deeds will not be wronged and that the traditional virtues of the Chinese nation will be carried forward.

However, in the debate about "what is the truth" caused by our expectation that good people will not be wronged, "Do you need to help the old man when he falls down" has become more and more a problem.

In fact, since the Peng Yu case, there have been countless acts of kindness to help others and be brave. One by one, the "most beautiful" figures silently declare with their own actions that truth, goodness and beauty have never left us and will always exist around us. At any time, when paying attention to the controversial case of "false accusation", we must not forget that "the most beautiful" is far more than "false accusation".

To carry forward the truth, goodness and beauty, it is necessary to punish the false, evil and ugly, and to punish the false, evil and ugly is also to protect the truth, goodness and beauty. However, in order to prevent us from going too far on the road of "degeneration" and forgetting the purpose of departure, we need to treat the tributaries and the mainstream comprehensively and fairly, so as not to let "good deeds be blackmailed" and prevent the fallacy of "social moral decline" from polluting the public psychology and hurting social moral conscience.

Everyone may be in danger. Look at your heart. When you are in danger, there will be no doubt about whether you should help others or whether you will be framed. If you pay too much attention to the results when someone needs help, or even worry about whether you will be accused, you will definitely miss the best rescue opportunity.

It is true that it takes not only courage but also wisdom to help others and go forward bravely. If you don't have professional rescue knowledge, you may wish to turn to professional institutions and use communication equipment.

Article 3: Should the old man be helped when he falls (debate material)

Should the old man be helped when he falls?

1. We are striding from "acquaintance society" to "stranger society". In the society of strangers, we have lost the connection of "human feelings and blood". In the face of strangers coming and going in the city, in addition to legal supervision, we also need to maintain communication with others and society, and fulfill our social responsibilities with contractual rationality including civic quality and civic spirit.

The fracture of trust intensifies the degradation of morality-"I don't correct people" calls for trust rather than morality, and moral fear of reaching out is the pain of social trust crisis. It is useless to preach in general. We should let the civic spirit grow up as soon as possible, repair the bond of social trust, and realize the fundamental moral redemption.

"safe collection"

Failure to help is an act of moral decay, social retrogression and being despised and spurned by the whole society. Helping talents is a just and bright act that the whole society should really carry forward and protect. We should, as always, carry forward the traditional virtues of the Chinese nation, and don't let a few occasional negative examples mislead us. Why is Wu's "supporting body" so prosperous? Prove that evil is invincible, and feel free to do what you think is right, so that people will spread warmth and love and society will be harmonious and happy. Those who are swayed by considerations of gain and loss, selfish, timid and afraid to help are the real villains. Front view (1)

Help!

Not to mention that you are a highly educated cultural person, anyone with a conscience will do so. "Being old for me and being old for people" is a traditional virtue left by China for thousands of years, which is culture; It is human nature that the old man who has been inconvenient to move accidentally falls down and helps people passing by. Helping the disabled and the elderly is a consciousness without thinking through the brain.

Our newspaper 2 1 reported that "Guangzhou women help the elderly to warm people's hearts" went out of the street, and "whether the elderly should be helped when they fall down" once again caused heated discussion. It is natural for an old man to give him a hand when he falls, but why has it become a big deal in China? People have to sigh again: "should the old man be helped when he falls?" 1300 million people need to discuss? " Dare to help and praise; Dare not help, considerate, what netizens commented between the lines revealed is a kind of helplessness for the elderly who want to help but dare not help.

Should the old man be helped when he falls?

On the night of 18, two brave local young women gave their affirmative answers when many people were afraid to lend a helping hand to the elderly who fell to the ground. This move caused a heated discussion among netizens on the Internet. Many netizens lamented that the insignificant actions of two Guangzhou girls made them see the dawn of social morality.

Some netizens pointed out that it is a good thing to help the elderly who fell. Why are people making a fuss now? Netizen Yoyo said: "It used to be a very common thing-grandma fell down, so it was natural to come forward to help. But in China, it became news, which was really shocking. "

"It used to be a very common thing, but because of the current society and previous negative events, people are afraid that helping the elderly will get into trouble, thus building a wall between people and becoming more and more indifferent. This thing just tells everyone that not everyone is so ugly. " Netizen "Shungeyuan Property" said. Many netizens pointed out that it is under the continuous fermentation of a series of negative events that these insignificant good things will become so "commendable".

While many netizens affirmed that girls helped the elderly, some netizens said that they were afraid to help because they were worried that "good intentions would not be rewarded". Netizen "frog snake" said: "It's not that we have no conscience, everyone has it. I believe many people consciously want to help. But dare not, people are sinister! " Some netizens even bluntly said: "It's not that I don't want to help, but that I dare not help. If grandma plays tricks, isn't that girl difficult to argue? " Therefore, some netizens suggested that how to set up a legal system to protect the help-seekers and recipients is the key to solving the problem.

Some netizens creatively suggested that saving the elderly who fell down is not a moral issue, but a technical issue. The netizen said, "It's best to call an ambulance at 1 12, because the old man fell and the situation is more complicated. Even if the parties or their families don't bite back, it may be because of improper care and good intentions. The spirit is commendable, but I think it is not handled properly! " Netizen "God helps those who help themselves" said: "How many netizens really know about artificial respiration, common sense of fire fighting, survival in the wild and self-help from accidental injuries? Therefore, when we don't know anything, brute force is a taboo for emergency rescue. "

Zhao Guangjun: Take photos before helping others.

Many celebrities also took part in the big discussion.

Zhao Guangjun, a national moral model and the host of Zhao Guangjun Life Hotline, said that we should learn to protect ourselves before helping others. "I think doing good doesn't mean not protecting yourself. Since such a case has emerged, you should respond and reflect, and don't easily sacrifice your reputation and interests. " Volunteers should keep "three photos" when they rescue. That is, take photos of the fallen old man, and ask passers-by to take photos of themselves and the fallen old man and leave the contact information of passers-by. 120 when the ambulance arrives, the probability of being framed will be greatly reduced if the nurse takes photos to save the card.

In addition, Zhao Guangjun also called on the government to establish a corresponding reward and punishment mechanism from the legal level, and should set up a "framed crime" to form a protection mechanism for good people, which can greatly improve the social atmosphere.

In this regard, Ma Zhi Hai, a well-known media person, has different views. He thinks it is natural for passers-by to help the old man when he falls. Now it's a feat of going through fire and water, making headlines! "Human life is equal and priceless. It is shameless to measure the value of human life with the transformation of interests. Therefore, even such discussions are shameless. " However, there are also more and more shameless discussions, such as "Should the old man be helped when he falls?" .

However, Liao Xinbo, deputy director of the Guangdong Provincial Health Department, believes that whether to help depends on the situation. He once wrote in Weibo: "Don't rush to help, how can this be indifference?" If it can't be saved, shouldn't the saved be fooled to accelerate the death of others? So, don't be impetuous. Learning a little medical knowledge will not harm you, let alone others. "

Shanghai: Nobody dares to help the old man when he falls.

At 4 o'clock on the afternoon of September 2, an old man with crutches accidentally fell down on Zhonghua Road, Shangwen Road, Huangpu District, Shanghai, and his face was covered with blood. Although many passers-by saw it at that time, no one came forward to help the old man get up. Everyone just watched. After about 10 minutes, a passerby called the police. Two policemen from Laoximen police station quickly rushed to the scene to carry out rescue. The police contacted 120 ambulance to send the elderly to a nearby hospital for emergency treatment, and then contacted their families.

The 88-year-old man fell and suffocated without help.

At that time, it was less than 100 meters away from the home of the elderly in Wuhan, Hubei Province, and it was too late for the family to arrive one hour later.

Morning News On the morning of September 2, in Wuhan, Hubei Province, 88-year-old Uncle Li fell head-on in front of the food market less than 100 meters away from home, and no one on the crowd dared to come forward to help. An hour and a half later, he was taken to the hospital for treatment. Uncle Li died of suffocation due to nosebleeds blocking the respiratory tract.

The 80-year-old man fell during the morning rush hour, and no one dared to help the police pass by to rescue him.

On the morning of March 4th, an 80-year-old man accidentally fell to the ground in xushuguan town Huifeng Garden, Suzhou High-tech Zone. Many passers-by passed by, but no one came to help him. It was not until the police officers passing by the police station found out that the old man was lifted and sent to a nearby hospital.

At 7: 30 in the morning, Gu Laobo, who lives in HSBC Garden, went out alone. Unexpectedly, he fell to the ground because of the slippery road in rainy days and couldn't get up for a while. The old man's face was also scratched by broken glasses. People in the neighborhood are bustling, but no one dares to help. Du Fu, a policeman who is off duty at home, drove by and saw the old man who fell to the ground and was injured. He immediately got off with a towel to stop bleeding and drove Gu Laobo to the hospital for treatment. After the doctor's diagnosis and treatment, fortunately, the old man is not serious.

On the morning of August 10, an old man was lying on the ground, covered with blood, and no one dared to look at passers-by.

Help, lead the bike to foreign women to curse.