Xiao He chased Han Xin under the moon. If he hadn't caught up, what would have happened to Han Xin?

The story of Xiao He chasing Han Xin under the moon has been passed down through the ages, and friends who like reading history are no strangers. Yuanyuan is going to discuss a topic today. If Xiao He fails to catch up with Han Xin, who will Han Xin go to?

Let's look at the situation at that time. In addition to claiming to be the overlord of Chu, Liu Bang was named Hanwang, and Xiang Yu also named Wang, Sima Xin, Zhai Wangdongkun, Xibao, Yu Wang Shenyang, Han Wangcheng, Sima Chen, Dai Xie Wang, Changshan Wang Er, Jiujiang Wang Qing Bu, Hengshan Wang Wu Rui and Linjiang Wang * * ao. One of these kings is bound to be Han Xin's choice. If these kings are not, then Han Xin can only go to Xiongnu and Zhao Tuo.

Jokes belong to jokes. First, make a screening analysis of the objects that Han Xin may go to. First of all, Han Xin won't go to Zhang Han, Sima Xin and Dong Kun, who belong to the surrender series of the Qin Dynasty, because they already belong to tigers whose teeth have been pulled out, and their vigor and ambition have long been lost by Xiang Yu. Secondly, Han Xin won't go to Shenyang, Sima Chen, DaiXie Wang, Changshan II, Hengshan Wang, Linjiang Wang * * * Ao, Liaodong Wang Hanguang, Zangcha, Tiandu, and Tianan in northern Hebei. First, because these are all followers of Xiang Yu, they were crowned king because they responded to Xiang Yu and listened to Xiang Yu. And Han Xin belongs to the person who betrayed Xiang Yu, so he dare not and can't work for these followers. Second, these people have limited ability and energy, which can't attract Han Xin. Third, Han Xin won't go to Hanwang City and Qing Bu, the king of Jiujiang. Don't go to Hanwang City, because Hanwang City is surrounded by Sean, and there is no pit where Han Xin can squat. I don't want to go to Qing Bu, King of Jiujiang, because Qing Bu was born a prisoner, a professional thief, and his hegemonic pursuit and ideology are not on the same level as Han Xin. Finally, Wangtian City in Jiaodong was left behind. I feel unknown. Will Han Xin go to him?

First, because these are all followers of Xiang Yu, they were crowned king because they responded to Xiang Yu and listened to Xiang Yu. And Han Xin belongs to the person who betrayed Xiang Yu, so he dare not and can't work for these followers. Second, these people have limited ability and energy, which can't attract Han Xin. Third, Han Xin won't go to Hanwang City and Qing Bu, the king of Jiujiang. Don't go to Hanwang City, because Hanwang City is surrounded by Sean, and there is no pit where Han Xin can squat. I don't want to go to Qing Bu, King of Jiujiang, because Qing Bu was born a prisoner, a professional thief, and his hegemonic pursuit and ideology are not on the same level as Han Xin. Finally, Wangtian City in Jiaodong was left behind. I feel unknown. Will Han Xin go to him?

two

Yuanyuan boldly speculated that Han Xin would go to Shi Tian. Not because he has many cows, but because there are some cows behind him. Then let me briefly introduce the situation of Shi Tian Group. It is said that the world was in chaos at the end of Qin Dynasty. Tian Yan, a descendant of Tian Jia in the State of Qi, led his cousins Tian Rong and Tian Heng to expose the rebellion of Daqin. Tian Fei is very capable and prestigious in Qi. Three times five divided by two basically settled the old land of Qi, and then he became the king of Qi himself.

Later, Zhang Han, the general of Qin State, led a counter-insurgency army to besiege Wang Wei in Lin Ji. Wang Wei couldn't stand the blame and turned to the fairy for help. Tian Fei thought of losing his lips and teeth, so he did not hesitate to personally lead the rescue. As a result, he was defeated by Zhang Han, and Tian Fei himself burped. After Tian Fei's death, his cousins Tian Rong and Hotan made their son Shi Tian king of Qi, and continued to fight against Qin and later Xiang Yu. Although Shi Tian was the King of Qi, the military and political power was in the hands of two uncles, so Han Xin went to Shi Tian rather than Tian Rong and Tian Heng. So are Tian Rong and Tian Heng worth going to Han Xin?

Unable to choose to work for Xiang Yu and Liu Bang, Yuan Yuan thinks that Tian Rong and Tianheng Group are the most worthy units to apply for in Han Xin. The reasons are as follows: (1) Tian Rong and Tian Heng belonged to the old aristocrats in the pre-Qin period, and they had certain influence and foundation in the hometown of Qi. Moreover, the Tian brothers are corporal, and their comprehensive quality is still relatively high. All these factors can attract Han Xin to apply. (2) Some friends may not believe that He Tian Heng was not the only old aristocrat in Qi's hometown in the pre-Qin period, nor was he a person with high comprehensive quality.

Isn't Xiang Yu also conferring the descendants of other Tian nobles in Qi, such as Tian Du in Qi and Tian An in Jibei? In fact, the old nobles of Qi Guotian are not only with Tian Heng, but only with Tian Heng's ability. Xiang Yu's other heavenly kings were wiped out by his two brothers, and finally they were unified, and both brothers became Qi kings. This is also the reason why the Tian brothers have been fighting with Xiang Yu since the end of the anti-Qin war. (3) Tian Rong and Tian Heng were brothers who fired the first shot at Xiang Yu's hegemony. If they didn't stick to Xiang Yu in the East first, Han Xin's plan of using this path wouldn't work, at least it's not so easy to let Liu Bang enter Guanzhong.

This courageous, courageous, fearless and courageous leader was the most impressive and charming among all the governors except Liu Bang at that time. (4) The Tian brothers have an indomitable and indomitable heart. Tian Rong, the elder brother, died gloriously, while Tian Heng, the younger brother, continued to fight under the banner. They are like cockroaches that can't be killed in Qi's hometown, which makes Xiang Yu miserable and Liu Bang happy.

Han Xin deeply understood that the ultimate goal of people who wanted to achieve great things in the world at that time must be to defeat Xiang Yu. Because you don't aim at defeating Xiang Yu, annexing any vassal state will be beaten by Xiang Yu. Only by eliminating Xiang can we compete with other governors. The chef brothers have been carrying the anti-item banner with perseverance, and this kind of leader and group is exactly what Han Xin wants to pursue. Fighting against the sky and fighting against Xiang Yu is fun! It is Han Xin's greatest pursuit to help his master defeat the strong with the weak, turn around the dry Kun, unify the whole country and worship the general himself. The Tian brothers' conditions can satisfy him.

(4) As a strategist, Han Xin will definitely consider whether the geographical position of the troops he defected to has a strategic advantage in the world hegemony. In the Historical Records of the Emperor Gaozu written by Sima Qian, there is a scene in which a counselor named Tian Ken tells Liu Bang about the two best strategic geographical locations in the world. The original text is as follows: "Qin, winning by shape, rivers and mountains are in danger." The county is thousands of miles away, with a halberd of one million, and Qin has one hundred and twenty. Convenient land, soldiers from the princes, like a strategically located building. Fu Qi has evil spirits in the east, kindness of Jimo in the west, the solidity of Mount Tai in the south, the limit of turbid river in the west and the benefits of Bohai Sea in the north. The place is two thousand Li, the halberd is one million, and the county is one thousand Li, making twelve. Story Qin Ye. If you are not a child, you can't make Wang Qi. " What does this passage mean?

That is to say, Qin and Qi are the best places in the world, and Qin has a superior geographical position and is in danger of mountains and rivers. It is easy and pleasant to attack other countries geographically, but when others lead millions of troops to fight against themselves, it only takes 20 thousand people to keep the enemy out of the country. As for the position of Qi, it is also protected by mountains and rivers. Although mountains and rivers are not as dangerous as Qin, Qi is rich. The vassals also brought millions of troops to attack, and it took only 120 thousand men to defend them as strong as gold.

So it has been called "the ashes of time" since ancient times. Wrong, it's "East Qi and West Qin". Tian Ken told Liu Bang that neither place could be crowned king unless it was his own son. As can be seen from this passage, Han Xin, as a strategist, not only looks at people, but also at the geographical position he occupies. So in a word, deep personal bold speculation, Han Xin left liu bang, the first choice must be to find Tian Rong and Tian Heng. Of course, if Tian Rong and Tian Heng can really get Han Xin and use it with confidence, the historical pattern of the whole Chu-Han period will change greatly. Unfortunately, there are not so many hypotheses and ifs in history. The real history is that Xiao He recovered Han Xin, Liu Bang worshipped Han Xin as a general, and then Han Xin began to help Liu Bang gradually eliminate the vassal state until the Qi State established by Tian Rong and Tian Heng was finally eliminated. Then, Han Xin stood on the land of Qi, established himself as a "false king of Qi" and begged Liu Bang for a "true king of Qi".

three

Returning to the initial screening analysis of defection in Han Xin, I believe some friends will ask Yuan why he ruled out the possibility that Han Xin defected to Xiongnu and Zhao Tuo. Let me start with the reasons for excluding Zhao Tuo. We extract the original text of Sima Qian's Biography of Historical Records in South Vietnam as follows: "In the second year, a captain in Nanhai was seriously ill and died. He called Longchuan to make Zhao Tuo say," When I heard that Chen Sheng and others were in trouble, Qin Wei was helpless and the whole world suffered. Xiang Yu, Liu Ji, Chen Sheng, Guangwu and other counties are * * * gathering troops, tigers fight for the world, and China is uneasy, which is unknown. The South China Sea is remote, and I'm worried that soldiers will invade the land here. I want to build a new army and bring my own. When the princes change, I will be very ill. Moreover, Panyu is a dangerous mountain, blocking the South China Sea from east to west for thousands of miles. With the help of the people of China, it is also the master of a country and can build a country. The county magistrate had nothing to say, so he asked them to make an announcement.

"That is, he was sent to the South China Sea to do things. As soon as he died, he told Hengpu, Yangshan and Huangxiguan, "Stealing soldiers is coming, and it is urgent to retreat in self-defense! "Because the law is slightly used to punish the long collectors set by the Qin Dynasty, it is a pseudo-defense. The Qin Dynasty was shattered, and Guilin and Xiang Jun were immediately attacked and became the princes of South Vietnam. " It can be seen that both Ren Tao, the former captain of the South China Sea, and Zhao Tuo, the later king of South Vietnam, are adhering to the purpose of protecting the environment and people. A muddy water that has no intention of competing for the Central Plains, and a peace of mind to build a country in South Vietnam and watch the changes in the world. The measures taken by Zhao Tuo are also to close the pass leading to the Central Plains and send heavy guards to prevent the Central Plains uprising troops from invading.

Therefore, in the whole strategic policy, if Han Xin doesn't take it, it is impossible for Han Xin to go to Zhaojiatuo. Also, the armies of Zhao Tuo and Zhao Tuo belong to the system of Qin dynasty, which is another important reason why Han Xin can't go to defect. As for going to Xiongnu, Yuanyuan firmly believed that Han Xin could not have such a fashionable idea at that time, gave up American citizenship and asked to emigrate to Zimbabwe. If Han Xin really goes, then Han Xin may become the first person in "China Travel Theory".