What do you think of "Weathering with You" in which a city was flooded to save one person? Is this really a good ending?

1. Why do you think Hina should be sacrificed in the ending? She is an innocent person and lives so optimistically and strongly. The world never smiled on her, but she responded to the whole world with a smile.

Just because it can bring sunshine, it should be sacrificed for the world. What kind of bullshit logic is this? In the face of such natural disasters, humans should first learn to adapt. This is just like the trolley problem. No one can measure the value of his life.

As long as the bottom line has been breached once, there will be no bottom line again. This is an eternal truth. The reason why people are human is because

There is no moral restraint. As for degenerating into a beast,...

When society can justifiably ask an innocent person to sacrifice himself to save everyone. There is no plot in Weathering with You that shows that the ending is that after Hina is sacrificed in Weathering with You, it will be sunny forever and it will never rain again. I don’t feel very good about it this time. Sacrifice to Haruna will ensure that the weather will clear up for a while. Next time, I will find another Haruna to sacrifice. One is not enough. Two of them are not enough. Two is not enough, and even ten is not enough. , one hundred is not enough. As long as this is started, unless the weather continues to clear up, it will definitely develop into a premeditated, organized and planned massacre targeting Qingnu and her group!

2. It was also revealed in the plot that this situation has been going on for thousands of years, that is, it has been raining sacrifices and raining sacrifices repeatedly in these thousands of years. It's not a problem to keep thinking about procrastinating the problem without fundamentally solving it. Not every generation of goddesses is willing to offer sacrifices. Even if you hide

you won’t find them, such as the heroine. She is not your mother, she has to pay for you unconditionally.

For example, if an ordinary lighter cannot light in an open place, do you blame the wind? Shouldn't you invent a windproof lighter?

Of course, survival is the first priority of the species. If the people are desperate, then Haruna will undoubtedly die. Morality is definitely not as important as survival. At this time, each of us will turn into a beast. And to be honest, if this happens, I don’t know if I will become one of the persecutors. It will always be much easier to type online than to face it in person. This seems to be a question of collectivism and individualism. There is no wrong answer no matter how you answer it, but there is a very serious issue that we need to grapple with. That is, what if it clears up after you sacrificed a goddess today, but it rains again in a few years?

3. So I think the ending of the movie also expresses in a sense that human beings follow the way of heaven, do not sacrifice their companions, and build a future for mankind in the face of adversity

Didn’t we live a good life in the end? What’s wrong with this? What’s there to complain about? Isn’t this spineless? Yes, I also feel that those who died in the disaster were miserable. .

The development of human beings, no matter what era, has not experienced wars and revolutions. The happiness of human beings cannot be separated from the word sacrifice. When war comes to the door.

Some people may say that there is no solution to the rain. Let’s think about it from another angle: God was going to rain there, and you yourself wanted to build the city there. Who can blame you? The Arabs had to build cities in the desert, and then they were blown up by sandstorms several times a year. Do they blame the desert? Isn't this a shame? Human development is originally a process of fighting nature. You have only three ways, either to develop technology to overcome it, to adapt to it, or to stay away from it. At the end of the film, half of Tokyo was flooded, but it was still a good time.

4. Since it is raining from both sides, what is the benefit of sacrificing your companions? Is it just to relieve your anger? Who can let her become the protagonist, but I can't

It pissed me off so much that I quickly sacrificed it to her. It pissed me off so much that such a good ability didn’t serve me!

Let’s say she is dead. It hasn’t rained for three years. You can seize the time to work, and then save enough money to take your wife and children to immigrate.

Sacrifice her, that’s it. , when it’s your turn next

I just ask you if you are afraid and that’s it.

If you want to change other things and tell me to follow the way of heaven, I think there is still value in discussion, but the answer depends on the question, at least for this question

In addition to the following Rain has no other choice until the land becomes the ocean.

It is the unity and sacrifice of the Chinese people that regained the land and dignity and gained peace, rather than sacrificing women, treasures or land. You are now standing on the land that the martyrs fought for with their blood. Come and tell me: How about we sacrifice some people to pray for a better life? Just tell me whether this idea is shameful or not. Japan finally built a floating city. In my opinion, this means that they have experienced the temper of God and overcome difficulties. This is a manifestation of human progress and the tenacious will of mankind. Ah, just hanging on, just hanging on there, trying to make progress by making sacrifices?

5. Is the rainy day caused by Hina? No, it has been raining before Hina passed the torii gate. The essence of rain is that the god is in a bad mood. If Yangcai is sacrificed as a sacrifice, how long will it last for sunny weather? The gods have not promised that the rain will stop permanently if Yangcai is sacrificed. If it stops for two years, it will stop for one minute.

Zhong has no idea. After the woman was sacrificed, it will still rain and clear. Who will appoint the woman? The god of rain will designate her.

You sacrifice one person today, and if the gods are unhappy tomorrow, do you have to sacrifice another person?

When is Wan Yangcai not sacrificed? What will be the impact? The heavy rain is falling slowly, not torrential rain. It took two and a half years for it to be completely submerged. In theory, no one would be sacrificed unless money was thrown. At the end of the film, the floodplain area was indeed isolated. Instead of living as usual, people's property was sacrificed

to be precise.

If God chooses a child, she must be sacrificed. Then I think there is nothing wrong with the monster in Journey to the West that wants to eat children.

If you can’t defeat the monster, then sacrifice the child to keep yourself safe. Monsters also keep their promises.

You are just bad! When I saw the comment that Hina

should be sacrificed, I felt the same as Hodaka. She was only a 15-year-old child, and she was only 18 at the end. She should have her own life, she should Be responsible for yourself and your brother. The only thing you don’t need is to be responsible for the flooding in Tokyo! I bully little girls when I can't do anything. Of course, if you suspect that my motive for wanting Hina to live is that I also want to answer this question, then I admit it!