Is Fujian dialect in Penang, Malaysia closer to Zhangzhou dialect?

In fact, Singaporeans speak 70% of Fujian Zhangpu and Xiao Yun dialects plus 30% of Chaozhou dialect. They call themselves "Chao Fu dialect", also called "Fuzhou dialect", but it means Fujian dialect plus Chaozhou dialect. !

Penang, where people pay more attention to "chaozhou people", must marry or marry back to "chaozhou people", and Fujian people must marry back to Fujian people.

Therefore, the Chaozhou dialect spoken by chaozhou people in Penang today is the same as that spoken by Puning City and Chaozhou City in China, with the same tone. Hundreds of years have passed and it has not changed at all. !

As for Fujian people in Penang, I heard that today Zhangpu people and Xiao Yun people say the same thing! !

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

* * * This question has nothing to do with my grandson who often goes to Baidu. I wrote it. I'll explain it. I spent 85 years in Singapore and Penang respectively. Maybe my education is not as high as that of young people now. I've always been a doctor or a postdoctoral fellow. Our times pay attention to emotional intelligence (morality+common sense). I even heard of 2 1 century, and recently 10 ~ 65438. !

So I think it is necessary for me to remind a person to pay more attention to quality+EQ. Now is the "Internet Age", not the "Stone Age", and the smell of gunpowder is still so strong. Fortunately, that person is not with me, otherwise I think I will be killed and talk nonsense if I don't understand! ! ! ***

What the landlord asked was,,,

1)) "The same word", why does it sound different from "pronunciation" and "accent", and there is no mention of other loanwords and interventions! !

2)) Please read it clearly. I also said "I heard" (I didn't say I was sure). The accent of Fujian Minnan dialect in Singapore is the pronunciation+accent when talking to people in Zhangpu and Xiao Yun (even if someone wants to change to a bigger city, Xiazhang). In short, it is 10. !

So someone admitted that, "100, chaozhou people learned a lot of pronunciation and accent of Minnan dialect, and Minnan people also learned a lot of pronunciation and accent of Chaozhou dialect. After 100 years of communication and mutual influence, the distance between Fujian Minnan dialect and Singapore Chaozhou dialect has been narrowed. "

Excuse me, is the so-called "closer" equal to my Minnan dialect plus Chaozhou dialect? !

I also said that "Chao Fu dialect" is not the real Fuzhou dialect today. I just got back from Fuzhou. What people in Fuzhou, China say today is completely different in pronunciation and accent. I don't understand it at all, but 30 years ago, people from outside China couldn't get into China, so I couldn't do research! !

I want to add one more sentence. My late third mother was a farmer between Zhangpu and Xiao Yun. Her words+pronunciation+accent are the same as those in Fujian Minnan dialect that can be heard in Singapore today (except for the 3-4 Chaozhou dialect, the remaining 6-7 sentences are the same). My parents are pure 100% chaozhou people. !

I also dare to say that the Chaozhou dialect in Singapore is no longer pure, and it has entered the pronunciation+accent of Minnan dialect in Fujian.

What's more, Fujian people in Malaysia are mostly concentrated in the north of West Malaysia, Cantonese is spoken in the middle of West Malaysia (Kuala Lumpur), and Hakka is spoken in the south of West Malaysia and East Malaysia! !

If I don't have money, I'll be happy to pay for the ticket of "The Man" so that he can listen to it himself, instead of calling me "misleading" readers on the Internet! !

Thank you for your attention! !