Does Shi Xia have anything to do with Lu Xun and his Japanese sister-in-law?

Lu Xun and his sister-in-law Yutai Mako were never lovers, but did they have sexual relations? This is what many people suspect.

Send me some letters from readers to talk about the relationship between Lu Xun and Yutai Zhang zhen. As we all know, the rupture of brotherhood between Lu Xun and Zhou Zuoren was caused by the contradiction between Lu Xun and Yu Taixin. What is the relationship between Lu Xun and Yutai Mako? Some scholars and non-scholars have made various speculations about this, but so far, the only basis for their speculation is Zhou Zuoren's last letter to Lu Xun. To illustrate this problem, please copy the full text of this breakup letter below:

Lu Xun:

I didn't know until yesterday, but the past is needless to say. I'm not a Christian, but I can afford it, and I don't want to blame it. -We're all poor. Before, all my dreams about Ross were illusory, but now I see the real life. I want to straighten my mind and start a new life. Please don't come to the backyard in the future. Don't come again. I wish you peace of mind, self-esteem and self-love.

July 18, as a person.

According to this letter, Zhou Zuoren suddenly learned a story yesterday and wrote this dear John letter. A "Christian" is usually regarded as a person who suffers humiliation. He said, "If he hits his left cheek, he will stretch his right cheek." Not a Christian, that is, not the kind of person who is humiliated. Then, "the past", in Zhou Zuoren's view, is an insult to him and he will never accept it. "Dream of Roses" seems to refer to the long-term family life of my brother Yiyi. This "past" proves the "untrue" of this hypothesis. What you see now, when you wake up, may be "real life" So he wanted to change his past thoughts and start a new life that was no longer a rose dream, which meant that he had to break up with Lu Xun. At that time, Zhou lived in Badaowan 1 1, Zhou Zuoren, Yu Taizai and their children lived in the backyard, their mother lived in the Intermediate People's Court, and Lu Xun and Zhu An lived in the southernmost front yard. Lu Xun is not allowed to go to the backyard again, asking him to "respect himself". He not only announced his break with Lu Xun again, but also asked Lu Xun not to have any contact with Yu Taixin. Then, "past tense", that is, what disputes exist between Lu Xun and Yutai Angel. And this matter can only be told to Zhou Zuoren by Yutai Shinko on July 17.

What is this "old thing"? Whether Zhou Zuoren or Lu Xun, the Zhou family kept their mouths shut. Some people speculate on the reason why Lu Xun and Zhou Zuoren broke up, but they can't agree. After Lu Xun's death, Yu Dafu published some opinions on this matter in Book City magazine of 1938. He said: "According to Feng Ju's judgment, this is a misunderstanding between their brothers. Mrs. Zhou Zuoren of Japan even said that Lu Xun did not respect her. " Feng Ju, a native of Zhang Fengju, is a teacher of Chinese Department in Peking University and a good friend of Zhou Zuoren. The information he revealed may come from somewhere. After the founding of the People's Republic of China, Lu Xun became a saint and became more and more sacred. It is said that the breakdown of brotherhood is entirely a difference in political ideology. The relationship between Lu Xun and Yutai Angel, even the most famous Memories of Lu Xun and Lu Xun's Chronicle, has been avoided and become a forbidden area for Lu Xun's research. This situation continued until1the early 1980s.

The more it is listed as a restricted area, the more people will whisper. It is better to know the truth than to make people whisper to each other, so as not to damage Lu Xun's true image. The fourth edition of Lu Xun Biography published by 1980 first published Zhou Zuoren's last letter to Lu Xun. Later, I read Ni Jun's Literary and Art Newspaper in Lu Xun's research materials, and thought that the contradiction between Lu Xun and Yu Dafu was caused by family economic problems. After the whole family moved to Badaowan, Shinko was in charge. At that time, Zhou Zuoren was a professor at Peking University and took part-time classes in several schools. His monthly income is above 500 yuan; Lu Xun's salary is 300 yuan per month, and several schools earn part-time jobs. The two brothers use their pocket money to buy books and so on. Then give it to angels every month, and the price is always higher than that in 600 yuan. You don't have to pay rent. There are eleven family members and two regular workers. Although the population is large, if properly arranged, life can be quite rich or accumulated. Angel doesn't spend money frugally, just in front of him. She not only spends it every month, but also makes ends meet. If the money is not enough, Lu Xun plans, but Zhou Zuoren ignores it. Lu Xun had to borrow money, constantly paying off old debts and borrowing new ones. This is recorded in Lu Xun's diary. In this case, Lu Xun inevitably said some thrifty words, so contradictions arose. Zhou Zuoren was not involved in such contradictions. Zhou Zuoren wrote this farewell letter when his new son "told" the past. However, Ni's article did not further explore the relationship between Lu Xun and Yutai. Since then, articles about the relationship between Lu Xun and Yutai Angel have gradually increased, causing various speculations.

In all kinds of speculations, 1000 ponies are people who catch shadows and chase shadows. Qian Jiaju published an article in Hong Kong, claiming that Lu Xun and Yu Taixin were originally a couple. According to Lu Xun's Brotherly Feelings, I Send a Letter to Thailand and My Name is Yutai's Letter, I often send money. It can be seen that the relationship between Yutai and Lu Xun is not ordinary, but the relationship between lovers. "In fact, since 19 12, Lu Xun has been working alone in Beijing and has to send money to his hometown Shaoxing. However, Zhou Zuoren and Yu Taixin, who live in their hometown in Shaoxing, should always support Yu Taijia who lives in Japan. Zhou Zuoren and Angel asked Lu Xun to send money directly from Beijing to Yutai's home in Japan, so that the money would not be sent to Shaoxing and then to Japan, which would increase the formalities and postage. Sometimes Zhou Zuoren sent small packages from Shaoxing to Beijing and asked Lu Xun to forward them to Japan, probably because there is a Japanese post office in Beijing, which makes delivery more convenient. So Lu Xun's diary records that "a letter sent to Thailand" or "a letter sent to Thailand" was sent to the Japanese post office. Qian Jiaju is so clever that he regards "Letter from Yutai" as "Letter from Yutai". Yu Taixin of Shaoxing often attaches a note to Zhou Zuoren's letter to Lu Xun, or signs it together, or attaches a note. So Lu Xun's diary often records "letters from his second brother and his wife". The situation of writing back is similar. Lu Xun's diary reads: "To the second brother and his wife. 1965438+ After Zhou Zuoren arrived in Beijing in April 2007, Yu Taixin sometimes wrote directly to Lu Xun, who wrote "Received a letter from his second wife" or "Received a letter from his son". Most of Lu Xun's letters to his second brother were addressed to his second brother and his second sister-in-law, and some were addressed to his second sister-in-law. Lu Xun never called these letters "letters from home". From 19 12, when Lu Xun arrived in Beijing, to 19 19, when Yu Taixin arrived in Beijing in August, during this period, Yu Taixin wrote 25 letters or notes to Lu Xun in the name of Zhou Zuoren or Zhou, and only 28 letters were written to Lu Xun, of which 20 were concentrated during Zhou Zuoren's illness in Beijing. On 19 17, Lu Xun wrote 36 letters and 36 notes to Zhou Zuoren and Zhou respectively. Judging from this kind of communication, there is no special relationship between Lu Xun and Angel. After 19 12, Qian Jiaju was not found in Japan and Shaoxing, and Zhou Zuoren and Shinko were not married in 19 12 for four years. The word "to Thai letter" in Lu Xun's diary made him suddenly come to the conclusion that "Lu Xun and Yu Thai letter are a pair". His bold assumptions and wrong arguments are really surprising.

Lu Xun and Yu Taixin have never been lovers, but have they ever had sexual relations? This is what more people suspect. The editorial department received a letter from readers saying, "At that time, it was very common for international students to have sex with girls. Lu Xun is in adolescence, and it is also possible to have sex with a female feather like Taixinzi. Later, he got married in Shaoxing, and Zhou Zuoren introduced his new son to him when he came to Japan. 1923 When Angel and Lu Xun had a sharp contradiction due to family economic problems, she told the details. This is what Zhou Zuoren said in his farewell letter. Of course, he can't accept it. " But in my opinion, this statement cannot stand scrutiny.

Before Zhou Zuoren came to Japan, Lu Xun didn't know Yutai Mako. /kloc-in the summer of 0/906, Lu Xun was recalled to Shaoxing by his mother to get married. A few days after his marriage, he went to Tokyo with Zhou Zuoren, who had gone through the formalities of going abroad, and lived in the Fujian Pavilion of Tang Lu Phase II, where Lu Xun once lived. It was late at night, and the two brothers lived in the same room. 1907 In the spring, the two brothers moved to the Sino-Vietnamese Pavilion in Dongzhu Town, their hometown not far from Fujian Pavilion. They rented two rooms, smaller than the carefree ones, but the food was not good. 1April, 908, Xu Shoushang found a house at No.7 Luzi, Fan Shi Town, his hometown. This is the place where the famous writer Natsume Soseki lives. He forced Lu Xun and Zhou Zuoren to live, and there were two other international students, five of whom were called May 4th Movement. Lu Xun and Zhou Zuoren met Yu Taixin here, a poor girl with a round face and quick work. She is not a maid, but a cook who cooks for guests. Soon, the girl seems to have a soft spot for the youngest guest, Zhou Zuoren, and the two are getting closer. The rooms here are clean, the gardens are wide and the flowers and trees are lush, but the rooms and meals are expensive. I have lived here for less than ten months. In the winter of 1908, Brother Zhou and Xu Shoushang moved to Shifandi, Xipian Town 19. Yutai Mako continued to provide them with food. More than two months later, Zhou Zuoren proposed to Lu Xun to marry Yu Taixin, and Lu Xun said that he did not object.

1in the spring of 909, Xu Shoushang planned to return to China to teach. Lu Xun said to him, "It's good to have you back in China. I can only go back to China because Meng is getting married. Since then, the cost has increased. I have to find something. " 1June, 909, Zhou Zuoren married Yu Taixin, and they still lived at 19 after marriage. In August of the same year, Lu Xun returned to work. Lu Xun and Zhou Zuoren met in Taixin at the same time. A few months later, Zhou Zuoren's marriage relationship with her was clarified, and she was formally married more than half a year later. In this love process, Lu Xun can't get involved, let alone have sex with Zhou Zuoren before he is introduced. Readers' letters are representative, but I'm afraid they are just speculations, which are not in line with the actual situation.

So, what does the "past" of 0755 to 79000 in Zhou Zuoren's last letter mean, that is, 0755 to 79000? The author thinks that Yu Taixin can't "report" that Lu Xun had sex with her. You "report" Lu Xun out of thin air, don't you also "report" yourself out of thin air? Here is some circumstantial evidence. Zhou had married Yu, but the relationship broke down. Zhou met Wang Yunru in Shanghai. Lu Xun married Zhu An, but he did not marry Xu Guangping in Shanghai. Yu Taixin often laughs in front of Zhou Zuoren, saying that his brother is polygamous, so Zhou Zuoren is unreliable. He even suspected that he had an affair when he went to visit relatives in Japan on July 1934. Until his later years, Mako kept repeating such accusations, which made Zhou Zuoren very unhappy. This incident also reflects from the side: If Yu Taixin's son "reported" that she had sex with Lu Xun, who would laugh at "brother polygamy"? What qualifications does she have to suspect and accuse Zhou Zuoren of having an affair? Therefore, Yu Taixin's "report" must be Lu Xun's ulterior motives for her, and she sternly refused. The so-called "disrespect place" for her. Of course, this is something that Zhou Zuoren can't tolerate. Another circumstantial evidence. After the brotherhood broke up, Lu Xun left Badaowan, found a temporary residence in Zhuanta Hutong, and went to Badaowan to pick up the rest. Unexpectedly, Zhou Zuoren and his wife had a big fight. On June 1924, 1 1 day, the diary recorded the following passage:

In the afternoon, go to Badaowan Building to get books and utensils, and compare with the West Building. His wife emphasized abuse and beatings, and recruited Xu He by phone for a long time. His wife told me about my crime and said a lot of dirty words. Ji Meng kept the round place, and finally took out books and utensils.

The public announcement of Lu Xun's "crime" this time must be because of Lu Xun's ulterior motives, how much he wanted her and how nasty he was, so "he used to scold a lot", but this can't be the way Lu Xun had sex with her. Otherwise, how could Zhou Zuoren "save the Rightists" when he made a mistake? In a word, some people suspect that Yu Taixin once "informed" Zhou Zuoren that Lu Xun had sexual relations with her, which is both unfounded and unreasonable.

So, is it possible for Lu Xun to believe Yu Tai? Without any evidence, it depends on Lu Xun's consistent behavior. Lu Xun's style in a big family is solemn, caring for his younger brother and sister-in-law, and willing to take responsibility. He is not a frivolous or romantic person. As mentioned above, write to him separately, with Zhou Zuoren or Zhou attached to the letter; Fang Zi also wrote many letters to him, and his reply was attached to a letter to Zhou Zuoren or Zhou. This shows that he attaches great importance to ethical relations. After Zhou Zuoren and his wife fell out with him, almost the whole family supported him. Needless to say, my mother insisted on living with Lu Xun. Zhou immediately wrote a letter to Lu Xun in Shanghai. Later, he and Lu Xun agreed that Zhou Zuoren "fainted" and became slaves of angels. Zhu An trusted her husband and asked to move out with Lu Xun. I borrowed money from Lu Xun soon. She borrowed it not from her sister's new son, but from Lu Xun. When Fangzi was ill in hospital, Lu Xun went to the hospital to visit her. Xu Xiansu is a student of Zhou and once lived in Badaowan. After living on campus, she often comes to see Lu Xun on Sundays. All this shows the family's trust and respect for Lu Xun. It can also be seen that Lu Xun is usually alone. Of course, they all know what Mako said to Lu Xun, but they know right and wrong in their hearts.

Not long ago, there was a saying in Chinese mainland that Yu Taixin was neurotic and sometimes even hysterical. At home, Lu Xun is indifferent to his wife and often chats with Angel in Japanese. Angel thinks that Lu Xun is particularly enthusiastic about himself. In Badaowan, my mother advised her not to take responsibility, but Zhu An couldn't. Let Lu Xun Shinko be responsible, Shinko thinks this is Lu Xun's special flattery. Over time, she thought Lu Xun was interested in her. Later, when the contradiction broke out, she regarded the thoughts accumulated in her heart as objective facts, and even thought that Lu Xun's normal practice was "disrespect for her." Although this statement is speculation, it can also be discussed for reference.