The motorcycle in the community was stolen, and the owner refused to pay the property fee on this ground. What happened afterwards?

The owner of each residential area needs to pay the property fee, and the owner will sign a service contract with the property after moving into the residential area. After the owner pays the property fee, the property will fulfill the corresponding obligations, such as cleaning, as the owner's wealth in the community. However, when some owners are dissatisfied with the residential property, they will refuse to pay the property fee to express their dissatisfaction, which is somewhat inappropriate.

Tianxin court ruled a property service contract dispute case, and the court asked the owner to pay the property fee and liquidated damages to the defendant property company. It is reported that in this property service contract dispute case, the owner is unwilling to pay the property fee because the owner's vehicle is lost in the community. The owner thinks that there is a loophole in the security of the residential property and refuses to pay the property fee.

It is reported that the incident occurred in March last year. Mr. Tan lives in a community in Tianxin District. He has never rushed back to the city from the countryside because of the epidemic. When the epidemic eased slightly, Mr. Tan was ready to go back to work in the city. As a result, after returning home, Mr. Tan found that his motorcycle parked in the parking lot of the community was gone.

After discovering that the motorcycle was missing, Mr. Tan called the police. After the police seized the video in the community, they stopped the investigation and found that a man stole Mr. Tan's motorcycle one night in late June 2020. Although it is certain that Mr. Tan's motorcycle was stolen, the thief who stole the motorcycle was never caught because it happened at night, the light was dim and the thief wore a mask.

Mr. Tan thinks that the loss of my motorcycle has a lot to do with the property. Mr. Tan said that when I bought a house, I signed a service contract with the property, which stated that there was a 24-hour security check. In addition, there is no security patrol in the surveillance video of the community. Mr. Tan thinks that the property management company charged my property fees but failed to fulfill its obligations, and asked the property management company to compensate me for my losses and exempt me from the property fees in arrears.

The property management company stopped communicating with Mr. Tan many times, but never reached an understanding. Finally, the property company sued Mr. Tan to Tianxin District Court.

The Tianxin District Court held that if Mr. Tan believed that the motorcycle was stolen because the property company failed to perform its obligations, he could also request the property company to undertake, continue to perform, take remedial measures or compensate for losses and other breach of contract obligations. But Mr Tan Can can't refuse to pay the property fee on this ground. In addition, the property company also produced special evidence. On the day of the incident, although there were no patrol security guards in the monitoring, there were indeed security guards who stopped patrolling in the community.

In fact, it is definitely wrong for Mr. Tan to refuse to pay the property fee. I lost my motorcycle, which can make the property bear certain obligations and even claim directly. But it is very wrong for Mr. Tan to refuse to pay the property fee.