Debate topic: The development of civilized habits among middle school students mainly relies on self-discipline (heteronomy)

Here is a speech about the four heteronomous arguments of college students, whether they mainly rely on self-discipline or heteronomy to develop their habits.

Thank you, judges, and hello everyone:

Today, stand On the court, I was honored to discuss this practical issue with my fellow debater. It was just as expected. The other fellow debater spent the entire court perfectly interpreting a final fantasy for us. Although the fantasy is beautiful, But it is a castle in the air. When you understand a debate topic, you need to grasp the concept well. The reason why the other debater had a hard time today is mainly because they did not clarify the concept. Let’s put this point aside for now, and let’s look at it. The other party is scratching his head today and talking about the benefits of self-discipline. Indeed, it cannot be denied. However, in the context of a lack of self-discipline or that self-discipline is simply unstable, its significance Where exactly? Just like calcium supplementation, supplementation is necessary only when calcium is deficient. Supplementation is the key. How to supplement it? According to the other party's logic, this becomes calcium supplementation. Using calcium to supplement calcium is not too ridiculous.

As the ancients said, "If you don't ignore it, you won't break it." Let me elaborate on our point of view again: College students’ good habits depend on others.

From my understanding today, this requires Heteronomy to take measures to ensure the formation of good habits. Now, let me take a step back and assume that most people can be self-disciplined. Does that mean that everyone just has to do their part? Collective civilization and harmony require the individuals to work with each other, and sometimes even to abandon some self-principles and interests. For example, when turning off the lights in the dormitory, the boss thinks that nine o'clock is better, the second boy's principle is that nine-thirty is better, and the third boy thinks that it is not too late to turn off the lights at ten o'clock. The three of them are relatively self-disciplined, but in order to achieve harmony in the dormitory, they must reach a common consciousness, which is heteronomy! How can independent civilized individuals form a civilized whole without unified standards? Throughout the game, the opposing debater kept avoiding our questions. I hope that the opposing debater will face our questions directly in the summary later!

Let’s discuss the superiority of heteronomy over self-discipline from a social perspective!

The more a system relies on personal virtue, the faster the loss of personal virtue will be, because virtue no longer has the institutional guarantee it needs: a system that does not rely on personal virtue is more conducive to personal virtue. , the more conducive to preserving personal virtue, because at this time virtue is still protected by the system. Take a look at the fact that our party has recently introduced a series of systems to regulate party members. The purpose is to enable party members to develop good personal habits and improve their own quality. Isn’t this consistent with the saying that “college students develop good habits through heteronomy”. If we only rely on self-discipline, then what is the purpose of enacting laws? If college students develop civilized habits by self-discipline, then why do we need the school to formulate a series of rules and regulations? A completely self-disciplined school is a school without order, a completely self-disciplined school Society is a primitive society without order, so heteronomy is better than self-discipline.

The discussion of socialism with Chinese characteristics at the 17th National Congress of the Communist Party of China is of outstanding significance to the construction of China’s inspection system. Hold high the banner of socialism with Chinese characteristics and require that any relevant Chinese prosecutors must adhere to the direction of socialism with Chinese characteristics. Even the system construction of our country needs to be regulated by social systems. Doesn’t the formation of good habits of our college students also ultimately require other disciplines? To regulate it? Furthermore, socialism with Chinese characteristics not only requires rich theoretical connotation and theoretical system, but also needs to be reflected through a large number of social regulations, including political system regulations, economic regulations, judicial regulations, procuratorial regulations, etc. In this sense, China’s procuratorial System construction is to build a socialist procuratorial system with Chinese characteristics. According to the provisions of our country's Constitution, the first of the three basic characteristics of our country's characteristic procuratorial system is "legal supervision." It is also stated here again: Our country’s procuratorial system is heterodiscipline acting on the basis of various departments in our country that can regulate themselves, which reflects that heteronomy is completely superior to self-discipline. I think my fellow debater can also see the advanced nature of our country's social system from this economic crisis! Since our country has proven successfully in the face of global economic turbulence that our society can still withstand the global economic crisis under the social prosecutorial system, then what reason do we have not to believe that heteronomy is completely superior to self-discipline.

Let’s return to our campus again. On our campus, you can often see signs similar to "Don't trample on the lawn" and so on. Doesn't this imply to us that your self-discipline is not enough and you always need other disciplines to regulate? The error-correcting function of heteronomy accompanies us throughout our lives, and we are not constantly learning and regulating ourselves.

Blind self-discipline is not enough. Class 07 students know very well that on campus, we have the road of "too many people walking" written by Grandpa Lu Xun. If we have to wait for self-discipline to solve the problem, the development of good habits for college students can only be achieved by I'm afraid it's like seeing flowers in the mist or looking at the moon in the water. New roads in the school will continue to be added.