Lingnan and Ningguta, which of these two exile places has worse living environment?

We can often see that the ancients were exiled to the frontier because of the mistakes in film and television works. Ningguta was the main exile in Qing Dynasty, and Lingnan was the exile in Tang Dynasty. Ningguta is located in the northeast frontier, which is not only cold, but also has very bad living conditions. Although Lingnan is desolate, some areas are still very prosperous. If we want to compare Lingnan with Gu Ning Baota, the living environment of Gu Ning Baota is even worse.

1. Ningguta Ningguta is now a place called Gucheng Village in Heilongjiang, which is an important border area in the northeast of Qing Dynasty. You should know that Gu Ning Baota is not like a tourist attraction in modern society, but it is very cold. Some people in the Qing dynasty also said that they would rather die than go to Ningguta. This shows that the living environment of Ningguta is really bad. Many prisoners died on a long road before reaching Ningguta, hungry and cold. Some people who went to Ningguta really went to purgatory on earth, because the Qing government neglected management, so it was full of violence and all kinds of bad human nature. Especially for women, it is very disrespectful.

Second, Lingnan Lingnan was the main exile in China in the Tang Dynasty. Although Lingnan in Tang Dynasty was not fully developed, some places were desolate, but some places were prosperous. In the history of the Tang Dynasty, many literati were often exiled to Lingnan. For example, Liu Zongyuan wrote a trip to Lingnan when he was demoted to Lingnan. Although the poem shows the desolation and resentment of Lingnan area. But the poem also mentions rivers, tourists and ships, so there is still social development here. Therefore, Liu Zongyuan led farmers to open up wasteland here to plant trees and build schools. So Lingnan gradually formed a small city.

Third, the society reflects that exiles are all sinful. So some people think that such people deserve to be exiled to extremely cold places and even die on the road. Some people think that the practices of the Qing Dynasty were too harsh and lacked human rights. But in any case, since we live in the socialist stage, we must abide by the law.